Abstract:Many writings emphasize the importance of Chinese culture to the 1989 Beijing Student Movement. Comparing the 1989 movement to the May 4th movement of 1919 and to the December 9th movement of 1935-36, this study finds the rhetoric and activity patterns of the 1989 movement to be actually more traditional than those of its forerunners. This is quite a paradox, considering the scale of social change in China during the 20th century. This article argues that the 1989 movement's traditionalist outlook can be explained by three structural conditions, all involving state-society relations. In comparison with the states of the earlier movements, the state during the 1980s had a higher capacity for repression. To avoid immediate repression, students tended to hide their real demands and goals behind safer and culturally congenial forms of action. Second, China in the 1980s had comparatively weaker independent civil organizations. Hence, the movement was poorly organized, and competing activities frequently occurred in the same time and location. What determined the efficacy of these activities then were less the actors' intentions than the perception of those who were observing the movement. This study argues that people's acceptance of particular movement activities is shaped by their perception of state legitimation. During the 1980s, most Chinese saw that the state's legitimacy lay in its moral performance, close to what was in traditional China. Therefore, people were more receptive to culturally and morally charged movement activities. This furthered the domination of traditionalism during the 1989 movement.

Organization and Place in the Anti-Us Chinese Student Protests after the 1999 Belgrade Embassy Bombing

Ecologies of Social Movements: Student Mobilization During the 1989 Prodemocracy Movement in Beijing

Nationalism and Authoritarianism: Student-Government Conflicts During the 1999 Beijing Student Protests

Protest events as institutions: stakeholder perceptions of the changing role of Serbia's EXIT festival

Student Nationalism in China

Built Environment in Urban Space Affect Protests: A Cross-Sectional Study in Hong Kong

Social Movements As a Dialogic Process: Framing, Background Expectancies, and the Dynamics of the Anti-CNN Movement

State‐Society Relations and the Discourses and Activities of the 1989 Beijing Student Movement

Spatial Meaning-Making and Urban Activism: Two Tales of Anti-Px Protests in Urban China

From the square to the shopping mall: new social media, state surveillance, and the evolving geographies of urban protest

An Angle on Nationalism in China Today: Attitudes among Beijing Students after Belgrade 1999

Variations in media framing of movements in China, France, and the U.S.: An intersectional approach

Internet and Activism in Urban China: A Case Study of Protests in Xiamen and Panyu

Dual Mediation and Success of Environmental Protests in China: a Qualitative Comparative Analysis of 10 Cases

Relational Repression in China: Using Social Ties to Demobilize Protesters

Mobile Communication and Relational Mobilization in China

Theorizing the Role of Culture in Social Movements: Illustrated by Protests and Contentions in Modern China

Mobilizing From Scratch: Large-Scale Collective Action Without Preexisting Organization in the Syrian Uprising

Pollution, Institutions and Street Protests in Urban China

From "Not In My Back Yard" to policy advocacy: The co-empowerment model between media and protests in China

The Embedding of Party Building in the Construction of "One-Stop" Student Communities in Universities: Action Logic and Coupling Mechanism