Accountability and Growth: The Costs of Village Democracy in China (Preliminary and Incomplete)
Monica Martinez-Bravo,Gerard Padro-i-Miquel,Nancy Qian,Yang Yao
2010-01-01
Abstract:This study uses a unique survey to study the impact of electoral reforms on income growth in rural China during the past two decades. Electoral reforms shifted the accountability of village leaders from higher level government towards villagers. We
nd that this shift in accountability reduced income growth and inequality across villagers. Interestingly, we
nd no e¤ect of electoral reforms on redistribution. Rather, the reduction in inequality is the outcome of the reduction in growth and the fact growth is biased towards the rich. We provide a simple model to show that in an environment where higher levels of government focused on income growth, electoral reforms can reduce growth by shifting the leaders e¤ort from economic growth to public goods provision; or by reducing the incentives of the leader because villagers perceptions of overall leader performance might be subject to shocks. Our empirical results suggest that both channels may be present. While we
nd an improvement in some social outcomes such as a lower number of disputes and a reduction in village personnel, such improvements are small. We thank Daron Acemoglu, Abhijit Banerjee, Pedro Dal Bo, Andrew Foster, Dilip Mookherjee, Rohini Pande, Scott Rozelle, and Lily Tsai for their insights; the participants of NBER China and Brown Macro Lunch for useful comments; Ang Sun, Jing Tao and Ben Zou for excellent research assistance; and Je¤ Blossom and Giovanni Zambotti at the Harvard CGA for GIS assistance. We acknowledge the PSTC at Brown and Stanford GSB for
nancial support. We are extremely grateful to the Chinese Ministry of Agriculture RCRE for sharing their data, and especially to Zhigang Wu and the team in Gansu Province for conducting the survey and assisting us in the
eld. We also thank John Giles for sharing his extensive knowledge and documentation of the RCRE NFS dataset with us. We acknowledge
nancial support from Brown University PSTC, Stanford Graduate School of Business and the National Science Foundation Grant XXXXX. yMIT: mmb@mit.edu zLSE, NBER, BREAD: g.padro@lse.ack.uk xYale University, NBER, BREAD, CEPR: nancy.qian@yale.edu {CCER at PKU: yyao@pku.edu.cn