In the Name of the Ancestors:A Comparative Reading of Ethnic Narratives on Either Side of the Taiwan Straits, with Examples from the Two Films, Red River Valley and Seediq Bale

Huiyuan Bai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-0677.2015.01.021

2015-01-01

Abstract:In the name of the ancestors, Red River Valley, a mainland Chinese film, and Seediq Bale, a Taiwanese film, tell stories of“how people of ethnic nationalities fight against the foreign invaders”with similar themes although, in such oppo-sitional structures as outsiders/locals and East/West, differences, inside and outside, between the two in points of view effectively refer to the differences of the cultural context between mainland China and Taiwan. As the“main rhythm”is reliant upon the modern ideology of state, Red River Valley has to frequently respond to the positioning of“the Han Nationality”, in which the Han people can be visually absent but must be culturally present. In contrast, thanks to the lack in Taiwan of the link of“modern state”in the native consciousness, the space of expression in the story has been compressed to a minimum in regard to“the Han Nationality,”with the result that Wei Te-Shen’s narrative mode, centred upon Mona Ludao, the tribal leader, seems quite“inside”. The only solution may possibly be a return to the inside of the historical memory of the masses and that of the emotional structure by facing the mainstream of our time, which is“the Great Reconciliation”.