Abstract:Objective: We examined attorneys' experiences, perceptions, and decisions regarding plea recommendations in child sexual cases. Hypotheses: We hypothesized that characteristics of the child (age, relationship to alleged perpetrator) and the report (timing of disclosure, consistency across reports) would affect attorneys' perceptions of evidence strength, likelihood of conviction, and plea recommendations. Method: We collected data from a national sample of actively practicing prosecutors (n = 217) and defense attorneys (n = 251) who had experience with child abuse cases. They averaged 18 years of experience practicing law, were slightly more likely to be men (53%) than women, and primarily identified as White, non-Hispanic (86%). In Part 1, attorneys answered general questions about their experiences in child sexual abuse cases. In Part 2, they reviewed materials from a hypothetical case that varied the child's age (5 years, 11 years), the child's relationship to the alleged perpetrator (familial, nonfamilial), the timing of the child's initial disclosure (1 week, 6 months), and the consistency of the child's report (inconsistent, consistent). They rated the evidence strength, estimated the likelihood of conviction, and assessed whether they would recommend that the defendant accept a plea offer or proceed to trial. Results: In Part 1, attorneys reported that they often have access to police reports, information about the alleged perpetrator, and evidence from the child when making plea recommendations. They said that it was important to know about prior allegations against the alleged perpetrator or by the child when assessing their credibility. They reported that the length of the sentence, sex offender registration requirement, and possibility of time served guided their plea recommendations. In Part 2, the consistency of the child's report influenced their decisions the most; they rated the evidence against the defendant as stronger when the child was consistent across reports than when the child was inconsistent. Additionally, their perceptions of evidence strength drove their recommendations. When the evidence against the defendant was stronger, attorneys thought that the defendant was more likely to be convicted at trial; thus, prosecutors were less willing and defense attorneys were more willing to recommend a plea. Conclusion: Similar to other cases, evidence strength and the perceived likelihood of conviction drive attorneys' decisions to offer or recommend a plea to a defendant in a child sexual abuse case. The consistency of the child's report plays a major role in predicting perceptions of evidence strength. Future research is needed to determine which other factors in child sexual abuse cases may also predict attorneys' perceptions and plea recommendations. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved)

"Parental Maltreatment, Regulatory Focus, and Recommending the Placement of Children in Foster Care"

Can Parenting Intervention Prevent Cascading Effects from Placement Instability to Insecure Attachment to Externalizing Problems in Maltreated Toddlers?

Professionals' decision-making about out-of-home placements following instances of child abuse

Child maltreatment: the collaboration of child welfare, mental health, and judicial system

The continuing role of material factors in child maltreatment and placement

Investigating the impact of Out-of-Home Care on early childhood development

Future Directions in Child Maltreatment Research

What do child maltreatment reports to Child Protective Services tell us about the needs families and communities are experiencing?

What Does Child Protective Services Investigate as Neglect? A Population-Based Study

Child custody disputes within the context of child protection investigations: secondary analysis of the Canadian Incident Study of Reported Child Abuse and Neglect

Examining Parental Factors as Moderators Between Maltreatment and Adolescent Delinquency

Factors Impacting Maltreatment Evaluation and Reports to Child Protective Services in Pediatric Substance Exposures

Sibling Separation and Placement Instability for Children in Foster Care

Associations of Mental Health Service Utilization and Mental Health Diagnosis with Placement Instability Among Foster Children in a Southeastern State

Adolescent Maltreatment in the Child Welfare System and Developmental Patterns of Sexual Risk Behaviors

Caregivers' Perceptions and Attitudes Toward Child Maltreatment: A Pilot Case Study in Tel Aviv, Israel, and Cleveland, USA

It's Complicated: A Longitudinal Exploration of Young People's Perceptions of Out-of-Home Care and Their Reflections on How to Change the Child Welfare System

Attorneys' experiences, perceptions, and plea recommendations in child sexual abuse cases.

Need for Foster Homes, Foster Parent Recruitment, and Licensure: Comparing Foster Parent and Child Welfare Worker Perspectives

Invited Commentary: Gaze Aversion and Unnoticed Phenomena

Predictors of Substantiation in Child Sexual Abuse Investigations in the United States