Abstract:Background: Information extraction from microarrays has not yet been widely used in diagnostic or prognostic decision-support systems, due to the diversity of results produced by the available techniques, their instability on different data sets and the inability to relate statistical significance with biological relevance. Thus, there is an urgent need to address the statistical framework of microarray analysis and identify its drawbacks and limitations, which will enable us to thoroughly compare methodologies under the same experimental set-up and associate results with confidence intervals meaningful to clinicians. In this study we consider gene-selection algorithms with the aim to reveal inefficiencies in performance evaluation and address aspects that can reduce uncertainty in algorithmic validation. Results: A computational study is performed related to the performance of several gene selection methodologies on publicly available microarray data. Three basic types of experimental scenarios are evaluated, i.e. the independent test-set and the 10-fold cross-validation (CV) using maximum and average performance measures. Feature selection methods behave differently under different validation strategies. The performance results from CV do not mach well those from the independent test-set, except for the support vector machines (SVM) and the least squares SVM methods. However, these wrapper methods achieve variable (often low) performance, whereas the hybrid methods attain consistently higher accuracies. The use of an independent test-set within CV is important for the evaluation of the predictive power of algorithms. The optimal size of the selected gene-set also appears to be dependent on the evaluation scheme. The consistency of selected genes over variation of the training-set is another aspect important in reducing uncertainty in the evaluation of the derived gene signature. In all cases the presence of outlier samples can seriously affect algorithmic performance. Conclusion: Multiple parameters can influence the selection of a gene-signature and its predictive power, thus possible biases in validation methods must always be accounted for. This paper illustrates that independent test-set evaluation reduces the bias of CV, and case-specific measures reveal stability characteristics of the gene-signature over changes of the training set. Moreover, frequency measures on gene selection address the algorithmic consistency in selecting the same gene signature under different training conditions. These issues contribute to the development of an objective evaluation framework and aid the derivation of statistically consistent gene signatures that could eventually be correlated with biological relevance. The benefits of the proposed framework are supported by the evaluation results and methodological comparisons performed for several gene-selection algorithms on three publicly available datasets.

Novel and Significant Spermatogenesis-related Gene Selection and Confirmation with Microarrays

Screening for Candidate Genes Related to Breast Cancer with Cdna Microarray Analysis

Expression Analysis of Micrornas and Their Target Mrnas of Testes with High and Low Sperm Motility in Domestic Pigeons (columba Livia)

Gene expression profile of 2058 spermatogenesis-related genes in mice.

Identification of Pig Reproductive Qtl Genes Based on Gene Set Enrichment Analysis of Mouse Microarray Dataset

Gene screening and expressing analysis of 2 058 spermatogenesis-related genes in mice

Identification of Testis Development and Spermatogenesis-Related Genes in Human and Mouse Testes Using Cdna Arrays

A Gene Selection Method for GeneChip Array Data with Small Sample Sizes

Analysis of the candidate gene sets correlated to the growth and development of pigs based on a mouse expression microarray and the comparative genomics

Comparative Gene Expression Analysis in Mouse Models for Identifying Critical Pathways in Mammary Gland Development

One Potential Biomarker for Teratozoospermia Identified by In-Depth Integrative Analysis of Multiple Microarray Data

DNA Microarray and Its Application in Andrological Research

Outcome prediction based on microarray analysis: a critical perspective on methods

Large scale real-time PCR validation on gene expression measurements from two commercial long-oligonucleotide microarrays

Very Important Pool (VIP) genes – an application for microarray-based molecular signatures

Comprehensive Transcriptomic Analysis of Mouse Gonadal Development Involving Sexual Differentiation, Meiosis and Gametogenesis.

Panoramic transcriptome analysis and functional screening of long noncoding RNAs in mouse spermatogenesis

The molecular characteristics in different procedures of spermatogenesis

Investigation of reproducibility of differentially expressed genes in DNA microarrays through statistical simulation

A novel high throughput screen to identify candidate molecular networks that regulate spermatogenic stem cell functions

Single-cell RNA-sequencing reveals the dynamic process and novel markers in porcine spermatogenesis