Abstract:In Ref. [1], Le et al. establish in the long-wavelength limit a universal shape for the returning electron wave packet in high-order harmonic generation (HHG) as a function of the returning electron’s energy. Based on this approach, Le et al. suggest a universal wavelength scaling law, ∝ λ−4.2, for the HHG yield for laser wavelengths in the range 3 μm ≤ λ ≤ 6 μm. This scaling law differs from the faster decrease of the HHG yield with increasing λ, ∝ λ−ð5−6Þ, predicted earlier [2–5]. Le et al. attribute this difference to the limited interval of wavelengths (λ ≤ 2 μm) used to solve the time-dependent Schrödinger equation (TDSE) in Refs. [2,3,5]. Since the HHG yield is a fundamental quantity for practical applications, any new scaling law for λ≳ 3 μm must be clearly justified owing to its importance for planning experiments involving the generation of extreme ultraviolet radiation by means of HHG using long-wavelength lasers. The apparent disagreement stems from the use in Ref. [1] of a different definition of the harmonic yield ΔY from that used in Refs. [2–5]. As noted in Ref. [5], the λ-scaling law depends on the precise definition of ΔY. In Ref. [2], the authors study “the scaling of an average harmonic yield, obtained by integrating the power spectrum over a fixed bandwidth.” (They integrate the HHG power spectrum over harmonic energy intervals of 40–80 eV for He and 20–50 eV for Ar.) In Ref. [4], the definition of harmonic yield from Ref. [2] was adopted for a monochromatic field, defining the yield ΔY in terms of the HHG power. For a short-pulse laser field, in Refs. [3,5], a definition of the HHG yield compatible with that in Ref. [2] is used; i.e., ΔY is defined as the energy radiated per unit time by the target atom (subjected to a laser pulse of duration T ) into a fixed harmonic energy range 1⁄2Ω1;Ω2 :

Scaling laws for high-order-harmonic generation with midinfrared laser pulses

Comment on "universality of Returning Electron Wave Packet in High-Order Harmonic Generation with Midinfrared Laser Pulses".

Wavelength Dependence of High-Order-harmonic Yield in Inhomogeneous Fields

Wavelength scaling of high harmonic yields and cutoff energies in solids driven by mid-infrared pulses

Scaling Law of High Harmonic Generation in the Framework of Photon Channels.

Relation of Harmonic Radiative Energy and Laser Phase in High-Order Harmonic Generation

Understanding molecular harmonic emission at relatively long intense laser pulses: Beyond the Born-Oppenheimer approximation

High-order harmonic generation in a strongly overdriven regime

A Scaling Law of Photoionization in Ultrashort Pulses

Emission Properties of High-Order Harmonic Generation

High-order harmonic generation from diatomic molecules with large internuclear distance : The effect of two-center interference

Correspondence of Below-Threshold High-Order-harmonic Generation and Frustrated Tunneling Ionization

Laser Phase Relations of High-Order Harmonic Generation

Scaling of laser-driven ion energies in the relativistic transparent regime

Verification of A Scaling Law in Few-Cycle Laser Pulses

Theory of high-harmonic generation by low-frequency laser fields.

Laser-Duration Dependence of Emission Properties of High-Order Harmonic Generation

Synergistic Longitudinal Acceleration and Transverse Oscillation in High-order Harmonic Generation

Time-Dependent Qed Model For High-Order Harmonic Generation In Ultrashort Intense Laser Pulses

Macroscopic aspects of relativistic x-ray assisted high-order harmonic generation

Signature of multi-channel interference in high-order harmonic generation from N2 driven by intense mid-infrared pulses