Abstract:Pre-service student teachers (PSSTs) should improve their metacognition in order to support their long-term development in their future complex teaching and learning lives. Although previous studies have explored the role of metacognition in learners’ learning effectiveness, the interrelationships pattern of metacognition elements in the process of metacognition and the metacognition characteristics of different genders and learning performance groups still remain unclear. This study clarified the intrinsic structure of metacognition, and gender and learning performance differences among PSSTs in an online learning community. We collected 33 PSSTs’ self-reported reflection data on six learning topics. A total of 1,188 reflection paragraphs were coded and 2,335 metacognitive utterances were presented based on the metacognition model. Subsequently, this study identified metacognitive components among different groups of PSSTs by comparing epistemic networks of self-reported reflections via epistemic network analysis. Results show that metacognitive components of PSSTs in an online learning community were mainly metacognitive experiences (36.32%) and actions (or strategies) (28.01%). Female PSSTs used metacognitive knowledge (21.4%) and goals (or tasks) (15.8%) more frequently, and the relationship between their metacognitive knowledge and goals (or tasks) was closer compared with male PSSTs. Specifically, the ENA results showed that the associations between metacognitive knowledge and goals (or tasks) (connection coefficient: 0.24) of females were stronger than those of males. In addition, the high learning performance group used metacognitive knowledge (18.7%) and goals (or tasks) (15.9%) more frequently, and they also had a closer connection between metacognitive knowledge and goals (or tasks) compared with the high learning performance group. Specifically, the ENA results showed that compared with the low learning performance PSSTs, high learning performance PSSTs’ metacognitive knowledge and goals (or tasks) had a higher connection coefficient (0.32). The findings provide broad and important implications for analyzing metacognition of PSSTs in the network environment, and provide new evidence for metacognition differences between different groups (gender and learning performance).

Gender Differences in Collaborative Learning over Online Social Networks: Epistemological Beliefs and Behaviors

Gender Differences in Virtual Community Knowledge Sharing

Gender differences in intentional social action: we-intention to engage in social network-facilitated team collaboration

Understanding the relationship between idea contributions and idea enactments in student design teams: A social network analysis approach

Identifying beliefs about the gender gap in engineering professions among university students using community detection algorithms and statistical analysis

Pre-service Student Teachers’ Metacognition in an Online Learning Community: an Epistemic Network Analysis

How Multimedia Influence Group Interaction in STEM Education An Epistemic Network Analysis for Online Synchronous Collaborative Learning

Exploring College English Language Learners’ Social Knowledge Construction and Socio-Emotional Interactions During Computer-Supported Collaborative Writing Activities

Gender Group Differences on Behavior Patterns in Collaborative Problem Solving Through LEGO

Gender Differences in Class Participation in Online versus In-Person Core CS Courses

Temporal Perspective on the Gender-Related Differences in Online Learning Behaviour

A Gender-Based Investigation of the Determinants for Information Sharing in an Open Learner Model Environment

The Influence of Internet-Specific Epistemic Beliefs on Academic Achievement in an Online Collaborative Learning Context for College Students

Idea Improvement and Socially Shared Regulation Matter in Cross-Cultural Online Collaborative Learning

A Phenomenographic Study into Conceptions of Social Relations in Online Collaborative Learning - Case Study of China Higher Education Learners

The relationships between social participatory roles and cognitive engagement levels in online discussions

Equity in Group Work Methodologies

Peer interaction and social network analysis of online communities with the support of awareness of different contexts

Role Analysis of CSCL Online Synchronous Dialogue from the Perspective of Social Network Analysis - Researching Collaborative Learning based on Tencent Online Documents as An Example.

Gender Differences in the Continuance of Online Social Networks

The hidden gender effect in online collaboration: An experimental study of team performance under anonymity