To Leave or To Stay? The Decision Context, Self-Images, and Owner-Managers' Persistence Decisions

fei zhu,stewart thornhill

2012-01-01

Abstract:Underperforming ventures are those whose performance falls short of the ownermanager’s expectations for a long period of time but whose future is not a clear failure. Persistence decisions about underperforming ventures are influenced by the environment and owner-managers’ individual characteristics. Previous research leaves two research gaps. First, our knowledge about which and how individual characteristics may affect owner-managers’ persistence decisions is still limited. Furthermore, owner-managers assume multiple roles in society and have opportunities to imagine a different future. Their decisions thus are affected by role demands and perceptions of the future. The growing interest in contextualizing entrepreneurship suggests the importance of putting persistence decisions in a broad social context and investigating the complexity of ownermanagers’ persistence decisions when owner-managers are facing multiple influences from the decision context. To fill in the above two research gaps, I put persistence decision making in a decision context consisting of venture attachment, family time pressure, social approval pressure, and personal options outside the venture. In this dissertation, I strive to address one research question: how do the decision context and two self-images—psychological capital and fear of failure—jointly influence owner-managers’ persistence decisions? I designed a metric conjoint experiment to answer this question. The experiment consists of 33 decision scenarios, each of which is a combination of a certain level of the abovementioned four decision context factors. Ninety owner-managers of smalland mediumsized enterprises participated in my study, and were asked to indicate the extent to which