Book Review: David Machin, Analysing Popular Music: Image, Sound, Text

Haicui Zheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0957926513486580b

IF: 1.8

2014-01-01

Discourse Studies

Abstract:‘as’ structure in citations, and how these choices reveal the writers’ evaluation of their sources. In Chapter 11, Ramona Tang further reaffirms her critique of the negative way in which ESL/EFL participation in academic discourses is mostly framed. Tang presents us with personal and professional narratives from several NNS academics, and – based on their experiences as well as her own – argues for a more positive framing of the discussion about ESL/EFL speaker discourses and a better recognition of ESL/EFL scholars’ potential to contribute to their disciplinary communities. This remarkable book sheds interesting light on the complex realities experienced by many ESL/EFL students and scholars, who live and write in English in such geographically and institutionally diverse countries as Australia, China, Japan, Italy and Poland. I highly recommend it to anyone interested in NNS written discourse, wishing to understand these complexities better. As a teacher of academic writing and a non-native speaker of English, I often grapple with language problems in texts written by my students or by myself – and, in this respect, I personally find many of its chapters pedagogically useful. But – above all – this book has deepened my understanding of ‘writing as social practice’ (p. 246) and has raised my awareness of the complex social and cultural issues involved in writing in academia across the world.