Abstract:DAMAS, DAMAS2, NNLS, Fourier-based NNLS, CLEAN and CLEAN-SC are typical deconvolution methods, which have been used in the visualization of acoustic sources based on beamforming to improve the spatial resolution and the dynamic range effectively. It is of great significance to demonstrate and compare properties of these methods comprehensively. In this paper, these methods are applied to cross-spectral imaging function (CSIF) beamforming with auto-spectra exclusion and their properties are demonstrated and compared with each other first by computational simulations consisting of a single source, two incoherent sources and two coherent sources. All the deconvolution methods can visualize single source or incoherent sources in the region where the assumption of shift invariant point spread function is valid accurately and clearly. Not only the spatial resolution is improved dramatically, but also the sidelobes are eliminated effectively. In addition, these methods rank in a diminishing sequence of sidelobe elimination ability from CLEAN-SC, CLEAN, DAMAS, Fourier-based NNLS, NNLS to DAMAS2. When the sources are out of the valid region, only DAMAS, NNLS, CLEAN and CLEAN-SC succeed in visualizing the sources and CLEAN-SC and CLEAN acquire the cleanest source images, then DAMAS, finally NNLS, while DAMAS2 and Fourier-based NNLS fail to not only locate the sources but also capture the strengths. DAMAS, DAMAS2, NNLS and Fourier-based NNLS have good availability for coherent sources in the valid region. In contrast, CLEAN fails to remove sidelobes effectively and CLEAN-SC can only detect one source. DAMAS2 and Fourier-based NNLS also perform poorly for coherent sources out of the valid region. Additionally, DAMAS2 and Fourier-based NNLS consume a minimum of time to conduct a calculation, CLEAN and CLEAN-SC take the second place, whereas DAMAS and NNLS are the slowest. Then a series of experiments are performed on small loudspeakers to validate simulations and compare robustness of these deconvolution methods in practical applications. Some practical factors such as the frequency response characteristic mismatch among the measurement devices have almost no influence on the results of CLEAN-SC, bring some change to the results of DAMAS, DAMAS2, NNLS and Fourier-based NNLS in terms of reconstructed maximum values, sidelobes, etc., and contribute plenty of extra sidelobe contaminations to the results of CLEAN. The conclusions play a guiding significance on the application of these deconvolution methods in practical engineering.

Comparison of Deconvolution Methods for the Visualization of Acoustic Sources Based on Cross-Spectral Imaging Function Beamforming

A robust super-resolution approach with sparsity constraint for near-field wideband acoustic imaging

Comparison and application of the far-field identification algorithms for multiple sound sources based on microphone array

Robust Bayesian Super-Resolution Approach Via Sparsity Enforcing a Priori for Near-Field Aeroacoustic Source Imaging

A Robust Super-Resolution Approach with Sparsity Constraint in Acoustic Imaging

Efficient Localization of Low-Frequency Sound Source with Non-Synchronous Measurement at Coprime Positions by Alternating Direction Method of Multipliers.

Sparse Deconvolution Method for Ultrasound Images Based on Automatic Estimation of Reference Signals.

Deconvolution Algorithms of Phased Microphone Arrays for the Mapping of Acoustic Sources in an Airframe Test

Acoustic Source Localization in a Reverberant Environment Based on Sound Field Morphological Component Analysis and Alternating Direction Method of Multipliers

Maximum Likelihood Deconvolution of Beamforming Images with Signal-Dependent Speckle Fluctuations

Comparison of Two State-of-the-art Rotating Dipole Sound Source Imaging Technologies: Models, Algorithms and Applications

Improving the Efficiency of DAMAS for Sound Source Localization Via Wavelet Compression Computational Grid.

Compression Computational Grid Based on Functional Beamforming for Acoustic Source Localization

A Comparison of the MEM and the MP-CLEAN Methods for the Image Reconstruction of Extended Sources with Simulated Visibility Data

Arrangements of Phased Microphone Arrays for Acoustic Source Localization Based on Deconvolution Algorithms

Deconvolution beamforming based on a fast gradient algorithm for sound source localization

Aeroacoustic Source Localization

CLEAN algorithm implementation comparisons between popular software packages

DAMAS with Compression Computational Grid for Acoustic Source Mapping

Inverse methods in aeroacoustic three-dimensional volumetric noise source localization and quantification

An Optimal Subspace Deconvolution Algorithm for Robust and High-Resolution Beamforming