Coast Guards: New Forces for Regional Order and Security
W. Bateman
Abstract:IntroductionNational coast guards for protecting national sovereignty in home waters are not new. The United States Coast Guard (USCG) in particular has a long history. What is new is that coast guards are being used more widely in the national interest, including as instruments of foreign policy in waters beyond the limits of national jurisdiction. Countries are preferring to deploy coast guard vessels and personnel in sensitive situations at sea rather than naval ships and personnel and to use coast guards for cooperative activities with other countries. Coast guards are thus emerging as more important national institutions with the potential to make a major contribution to regional order and security. These trends are particularly evident in the Asia Pacific region.The Western Pacific, the seas of East Asia, and proximate areas of South Asia are now the setting for some of the world's most perplexing problems of maritime management and jurisdiction. This region has complex maritime geography with many islands and archipelagos, narrow straits and shipping channels with numerous overlapping claims to maritime jurisdiction, and few agreed maritime boundaries. Uses of the sea are particularly intense with high levels of shipping traffic and resource exploitation. Southeast Asia in particular has become notorious for piracy and other problems of law and order at sea, including drug trafficking, illegal fishing, and people smuggling. Willful acts of marine pollution and the destruction of marine habitats are common.Concern exists about increased naval expenditure in the region and the possibility of a naval arms race increasing tension at sea unless there is a new focus on maritime confidence-building measures and other "building blocks" for regional stability. The challenge is to build a regional security environment in which countries do not feel the need for the types of naval capabilities currently being acquired. However, there are major stumbling blocks to the achievement of that environment.Maritime regimes need to be developed to bring order to the oceans and seas of the region. Maritime cooperation is a major component of the regimebuilding process and is essential for the effective management of regional seas, especially marine environmental protection, marine safety, resource management, and preventing illegal activity at sea. Coast guards may offer advantages over navies for cooperative activities. They might overcome sensitivities that inhibit naval cooperation and provide a means of conducting law enforcement in areas where the use of naval vessels may aggravate the situation.The Rationale for a Coast GuardThe 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) led to extended coastal state jurisdiction, particularly through the introduction of the 200-nautical mile exclusive economic zone (EEZ). Countries became more aware of the need to build institutions for the exercise of state power at sea, to establish national arrangements for managing offshore areas, and to acquire capabilities (ships, aircraft, and systems) for maritime surveillance and enforcement. Navies already had these capabilities. Thus the new law of the sea and the extension of maritime jurisdiction under UNCLOS were expected to provide additional justification for maintaining a navy, particularly for maritime policing. One observer spoke about "New Times for Old Navies" concluding that: "Turning warships into lawships is a rational way ahead for future international society in which the costs of war are dramatically increasing and the benefits clearly decreasing."'While coastal states have greater rights in adjacent waters under UNCLOS, they also have increased responsibilities. They have to maintain safety in their waters, protect the marine environment, and generally maintain good order at sea. The prevention of marine pollution, illegal fishing, and criminal activity at sea (such as piracy and the various forms of smuggling) are now as much a part of national security as is defense against military threats. …
Law,Political Science