Abstract:OBJECTIVES: Proponents of criminogenic risk assessment have called for its widespread expansion throughout the criminal justice system. Its success in predicting recidivism is taken as evidence that criminogenic risks tap into the causes of criminal behavior, and that targeting these factors can reduce correctional supervision rates and even prevent crime. This study challenges these assertions, by testing the implicit assumption that populations in which recidivism risk factors were identified are interchangeable with populations experiencing the onset/duration of exposure to the criminal justice system.HYPOTHESES: Exposure to the criminal justice system increases some of the risk factors used to predict recidivism; therefore, risk factors for recidivism and onset/duration of exposure to the criminal justice system are not interchangeable.METHOD: Secondary analysis of data from 503 boys followed prior to first arrest through early adulthood. Inverse-probability-of-exposure-weighted marginal structural models and fixed effects models were employed to test whether arrests and convictions increase antisocial attitudes, behaviors, and peers.RESULTS: Being arrested or convicted resulted in subsequently higher levels of antisocial attitudes, behaviors, and peers. Risks for recidivism, which include the effect of exposure to the criminal justice system, are not identical to the risks of exposure to the criminal justice system.CONCLUSIONS: Results caution against the uncritical expansion of criminogenic risk assessment from community corrections to policing, pretrial, and sentencing. Researchers and policymakers should engage with the social conditions that put people at risk of criminogenic risks and more cautiously communicate the scope of reform that criminogenic risk assessment can deliver. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2019 APA, all rights reserved).

Testing Social Support Theory: A Multilevel Analysis of Recidivism

The Role of Family Support in the Explanation of Patterns of Desistance Among Individuals Convicted of a Sexual Offense

Social support quality and availability affects risk behaviors in offenders

Social Support and Feelings of Hostility Among Released Inmates

Exploring the relationships between criminal self‐efficacy factors and recidivism

The Importance of Social Support and Coercion to Risk of Impulsivity and Juvenile Offending

Using Dynamic Factors to Predict Recidivism Among Women

Do individual characteristics explain variation in sanction risk updating among serious juvenile offenders? Advancing the logic of differential deterrence.

Explaining Male Sex Offender Recidivism: Accounting for Differences in Correctional Supervision

Building Bridges: Exploring Support Systems of Justice-Involved Individuals

The Path of Least Desistance: Inmate Compliance and Recidivism

Predicting Criminal Recidivism in Adult Male Offenders

Community relationship quality and reincarceration following rural drug-using women's reentry from jail

Monitoring changes in risk of reoffending: A prospective study of 632 men on community supervision.

Neighborhood Context and Juvenile Recidivism: A Spatial Analysis of Organizations and Reoffending Risk

Weathering Probation and Parole: The Protective Role of Social Support on Black Women’s Recent Stressful Events and Depressive Symptoms

An Examination of Prison-Based Programming and Prison Misconduct

Distinction between cortex and medulla in kidney transplant aspiration cytology and relevance to interpretation of results.

α3β4 nicotinic receptors in the medial habenula and substance P transmission in the interpeduncular nucleus modulate nicotine sensitization

A Public Administration Headache: An Evaluation Analysis of Prison Policy and Recidivism Toward Social Reintegration

Criminogenic or criminalized? Testing an assumption for expanding criminogenic risk assessment.