Abstract:Abstract Nest defense is an adaptive strategy used by adults to increase survival of independent young. However, the risk adults face by defending young from predators represents an important trade-off and parental investment theory predicts adults will modulate nest defense based on the value of offspring. We used a model of a black rat snake, a potential nest predator on our study site, to quantify nest defense in a population of gray catbirds in eastern Pennsylvania during the breeding seasons of 2017 and 2018. Specifically, we evaluated (1) the difference in nest defense between male and female parents, (2) the relationship between nest defense and nest success, and (3) how variation in nest defense was related to factors associated with offspring value. Although male catbirds tend to be larger than females, they did not defend their nests more aggressively than female catbirds. Response to the model predator we used was also not different between individuals whose nests were successful compared with individuals that failed. Although nests that contained more and older young were not defended more aggressively, our analyses did show that adult catbirds defended young that were laid earlier in the season more intensely than those laid later in the breeding season. In birds, earlier clutch initiation is associated with an increased chance of recruitment into the breeding population. Catbirds, therefore, follow predictions of parental investment theory because they defended offspring of higher value more aggressively. Significance statement Defense of young from predators is an important component of parental care. Nest defense represents a trade-off because although it should increase reproductive success by increasing offspring survival, it presents a risk to adults, thus lowering their survival. We studied variation in nest defense of gray catbirds in relation to offspring value. Although nest defense was not related to nest success, we did find that adult catbirds defended nests that were produced earlier in the year more aggressively than later nests. In birds, the timing of reproduction is linked to prospects of juvenile survival in such a way that offspring produced early in the breeding season are more likely to survive and recruit into the breeding population. As predicted by parental investment theory, catbirds defended young that represented a higher increase in fitness more aggressively.

Nest Helpers Improve Parental Survival but Not Offspring Production in a High‐elevation Passerine, the Ground Tit Pseudopodoces Humilis

Should sons breed independently or help? Local relatedness matters

Variation in parental investment preferences for nestlings of the Gray‐backed Shrike (Lanius tephronotus) in alpine environments

May brood desertion be ruled by partner parenting capability in a polygamous songbird? An experimental study

Increase of Parental Effort with Brood Size in a Nidifugous Bird

Nest construction and its effect on post-hatching family life in the burying beetle

Interplay of cooperative breeding and predation risk on egg allocation and reproductive output

Effects of extra‐pair paternity and maternity on the provisioning strategies of the Azure‐winged Magpie Cyanopica cyanus

Inequality among offspring, correlates of recruitment and lifetime reproductive success in a long-lived raptor

Parental provisioning is weakly age‐dependent and heritable in a small passerine

Variation in nest survival of three species of tropical plovers in Madagascar with clutch size, age of nest, year and El Niño effect

Horned Larks on the Tibetan Plateau Adjust the Breeding Strategy According to the Seasonal Changes in the Risk of Nest Predation and Food Availability

Foraging associations are related with helping interactions in a cooperatively breeding bird

Predation Patterns on Artificial Nests of Ground Nesting Pheasants in the Montane Forest, Southwest China

Effect of altitude on male parental expenditure in Mountain Bluebirds (Sialia currucoides): are higher-altitude males more attentive fathers?

Nest concealment is associated with reproductive traits across sympatric bird species

Phenotypic Consequences of Maternally Selected Nests: a Cross-Fostering Experiment in a Desert Lizard.

The effect of offspring value on variation of nest defense intensity in gray catbirds (Dumetella carolinensis)

Food supplementing peregrine falcon (Falco peregrinus tundrius) nests increase reproductive success with no change in mean parental provisioning rate

Risk‐Taking in Bluebirds After Exposure to a Nest Predator Relates to Parental Roles and Shows Little Cooperation Between Partners

Nestling-Care Decisions by Cooperatively Breeding American Crows