The Principle of Maximum Conformality Correctly Resolves the Renormalization-Scheme-Dependence Problem
Jiang Yan,Stanley J. Brodsky,Leonardo Di Giustino,Philip G. Ratcliffe,Sheng-Quan Wang,Xing-Gang Wu
2024-10-14
Abstract:In this paper, we clarify a serious misinterpretation and consequent misuse of the Principle of Maximum Conformality (PMC). In a recently published article~\cite{Stevenson:2023isz}, P.~M. Stevenson has claimed that ``the PMC is ineffective and does nothing to resolve the renormalization-scheme-dependence problem", concluding incorrectly that the success of PMC predictions is due to the PMC being a ``laborious, \emph{ad hoc}, back-door" version of the principle of minimum sensitivity (PMS). We show that such conclusions are incorrect, deriving from a misinterpretation of the PMC and overestimation of the applicability of the PMS. The purpose of the PMC is to achieve precise fixed-order pQCD predictions, free from conventional renormalization-scheme and renormalization-scale ambiguities. We demonstrate that the PMC predictions satisfy all of the self-consistency conditions of the renormalization group and standard renormalization-group invariance; the PMC predictions are thus independent of any initial choice of renormalization scheme and scale. The scheme independence of the PMC is also ensured by Commensurate Scale Relations which relate different observables to each other. Owing to the elimination of the factorially-divergent renormalon terms, the PMC series has better convergence behavior than the conventional series; it substantially suppresses any residual scale dependence due to unknown higher-order terms; and it thus provides a reliable basis for estimating the contributions of unknown higher-order terms. Thus, the PMC, based on the standard renormalization group invariance, has a rigorous foundation, eliminates the factorially divergent renormalon contributions, as well as eliminating unnecessary systematic errors which underly high-precision pQCD predictions. The PMC can thus be rigorously applied to virtually all high-energy hadronic processes.
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,High Energy Physics - Theory