Measurement of higher-order multipole amplitudes in $\psi(3686)\rightarrow\gamma\chi_{c1,2}$ with $\chi_{c1,2}\to\gamma J/\psi$ and search for the transition $\eta_{c}(2S)\to\gamma J/\psi$
M. Ablikim,M. Achasov,X. Ai,O. Albayrak,M. Albrecht,D. Ambrose,A. Amoroso,F. An,Q. An,J. Bai,R. Ferroli,Y. Ban,D. Bennett,J. Bennett,M. Bertani,D. Bettoni,J. Bian,F. Bianchi,E. Boger,I. Boyko,R. Briere,H. Cai,X. Cai,O. Cakir,A. Calcaterra,G. Cao,S. Cetin,J. Chang,G. Chelkov,G. Chen,H. Chen,H. Chen,J. Chen,M. Chen,S. Z. Chen,Shenjian Chen,X. Chen,X. Chen,Y. Chen,H. Cheng,X. Chu,G. Cibinetto,H. Dai,J. Dai,A. Dbeyssi,D. Dedovich,Z. Deng,A. Denig,I. Denysenko,M. Destefanis,F. Mori,Y. Ding,C. Dong,J. Dong,L. Dong,M. Dong,Z. Dou,S. Du,P. Duan,Jingzhou Fan,J. Fang,S. Fang,X. Fang,Y. Fang,R. Farinelli,L. Fava,O. Fedorov,F. Feldbauer,G. Felici,C. Feng,E. Fioravanti,M. Fritsch,C. Fu,Q. Gao,Xinlei Gao,X. Gao,Y. Gao,Z. Gao,I. Garzia,K. Goetzen,L. Gong,W. Gong,W. Gradl,M. Greco,M. Gu,Y. Gu,Y. Guan,A. Guo,L. Guo,R. Guo,Y. Guo,Yuping Guo,Z. Haddadi,A. Hafner,Shuang Han,X. Hao,F. Harris,K. He,T. Held,Y. Heng,Z. Hou,C. Hu,H. Hu,J. Hu,T. Hu,Y. Hu,Guangshun Huang,J. Huang,X. Huang,X. Huang,Yong-Feng Huang,Zhi-ling Huang,T. Hussain,Q. Ji,Q. Ji,X. Ji,X. Ji,L. Jiang,X. Jiang,Xingyu Jiang,J. Jiao,Z. Jiao,D. Jin,S. Jin,T. Johansson,A. Julin,N. Kalantar-Nayestanaki,X. Kang,X. Kang,M. Kavatsyuk,B. Ke,P. Kiese,R. Kliemt,B. Kloss,O. B. Kolcu,B. Kopf,M. Kornicer,A. Kupść,W. Kühn,J. Lange,M. Lara,P. Larin,H. Leithoff,C. Leng,Cui Li,Cheng Li,D. Li,F. Li,F. Li,G. Li,H. Li,H. Li,J. Li,Jin Li,Kenneth K. Li,Lei Li,P. Li,Qiyun Li,Teng Li,Wei Li,W. Li,X. Li,X. Li,Xin Li,X. Li,Yubo Li,Z. Li,H. Liang,J. Liang,Y. Liang,Y. Liang,G. Liao,D. Lin,Bingxuan Liu,B. Liu,C. Liu,D. Liu,Fu-Hu Liu,F. Liu,Feng. Liu,Hongbang Liu,Hengjun Liu,H. Liu,J. Liu,J. Liu,J. Liu,J. Liu,Li-Yu Daisy Liu,Li-Yu Daisy Liu,Landiao Liu,Li-Yu Daisy Liu,Q. Liu,S. Liu,X. Liu,Y. Liu,Z. Liu,Zhiqing Liu,H. Loehner,X. Lou,H. Lu,J. Lu,Y. Lu,C. Luo,M. Luo,T. Luo,X. Luo,X. Lyu,F. Ma,H. Ma,Lianliang Ma,M. Ma,Q. Ma,T. Ma,X. Ma,X. Ma,Yuming Ma,F. Maas,M. Maggiora,Y. Mao,Z. Mao,S. Marcello,J. Messchendorp,G. Mezzadri,J. Min,R. Mitchell,X. Mo,Y. Mo,C. Morales,N. Muchnoi,H. Muramatsu,Y. Nefedov,F. Nerling,I. Nikolaev,Z. Ning,S. Nisar,S. Niu,X. Niu,S. Olsen,Q. Ouyang,S. Pacetti,Y. Pan,P. Patteri,M. Pelizaeus,H. Peng,K. Peters,J. Pettersson,J. Ping,R. Ping,R. Poling,V. Prasad,H. Qi,M. Qi,S. Qian,C. Qiao,L. Qin,N. Qin,X. Qin,Z. Qin,J. Qiu,K. H. Rashid,C. Redmer,M. Ripka,G. Rong,C. Rosner,X. Ruan,A. Sarantsev,M. Savrié,K. Schoenning,S. Schumann,W. Shan,M. Shao,C. Shen,P. Shen,X. Shen,H. Sheng,M. Shi,Weimin Song,X. Song,S. Sosio,S. Spataro,G. Sun,Ju-Yong Sun,S. Sun,X. Sun,Y. Sun,Y. Sun,Z. Sun,Z. Sun,C. Tang,X. Tang,I. Tapan,E. Thorndike,M. Tiemens,M. Ullrich,I. Uman,G. Varner,B. Wang,B. Wang,Dan Wang,D. Wang,K. Wang,L. Wang,L. Wang,M. Wang,P. Wang,Peiliang Wang,S. Wang,W. Wang,Weiping Wang,X. Wang,Y. Wang,Y. Wang,Y. Wang,Y. Wang,Z. Wang,Z. Wang,Z. Wang,Z. Wang,T. Weber,D. Wei,J. Wei,P. Weidenkaff,S. Wen,U. Wiedner,M. Wolke,L. Wu,L. Wu,Ziyu Wu,L. Xia,L. Xia,Y. Xia,D. Xiao,Hao Xiao,Zhen-Jun Xiao,Y. Xie,Q. L. Xiu,G. Xu,J. Xu,L. Xu,Q. Xu,Qingnian Xu,X. Xu,L. Yan,W. Yan,W. Yan,Y. Yan,H. Yang,H. Yang,Liu Yang,Y. Yang,M. Ye,J. Yin,B. Yu,C. Yu,J. Yu,C. Yuan,W. Yuan,Y. Yuan,A. Yuncu,A. Zafar,A. Zallo,Y. Zeng,Z. Zeng,B. Zhang,B. Zhang,Changjin Zhang,C. Zhang,D. Zhang,H. Zhang,H. Zhang,J. Zhang,Jiajing Zhang,Jian Zhang,J. Zhang,J. Zhang,J. Zhang,J. Zhang,K. Zhang,L. Zhang,Shiquan Zhang,X. Zhang,Y. Zhang,Y. Zhang,Yanfeng Zhang,Yu Zhang,Z. Zhang,Z. Zhang,Z. Zhang,G. Zhao,J. Zhao,J. Zhao,J. Zhao,Lei Zhao,Ling Zhao,M. Zhao,Q. Zhao,Q. Zhao,S. Zhao,T. Zhao,Y. Zhao,Z. Zhao,A. Zhemchugov,B. Zheng,J. Zheng,Wenjing Zheng,Y. Zheng,B. Zhong,L. Zhou,X. Zhou,Xingxiang Zhou,X. Zhou,Xiaokang Zhou,K. Zhu,S. Zhu,Shihai Zhu,X. Zhu,Y. Zhu,Y. Zhu,Z. Zhu,J. Zhuang,L. Zotti,B. Zou,J. Zou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.95.072004
2017-01-01
Abstract:Using 106~million $\psi(3686)$ events collected with the BESIII detector, we measure multipole amplitudes for the decay $\psi(3686)\rightarrow\gamma\chi_{c1,2}\to\gamma\gamma J/\psi$ beyond the dominant electric-dipole amplitudes. The normalized magnetic-quadrupole amplitude for $\psi(3686)\rightarrow\gamma\chi_{c1,2}\rightarrow\gamma\gamma J/\psi$ and the normalized electric-octupole amplitudes for $\psi(3686)rightarrow\gamma\chi_{c2}$,~$\chi_{c2}\rightarrow\gamma J/\psi$ are determined. The M2 amplitudes for $\psi(3686)\rightarrow\gamma\chi_{c1}$ and $\chi_{c1,2}\rightarrow\gamma J/\psi$ are found to differ significantly from zero and are consistent with theoretical predictions. We also obtain the ratios of M2 contributions of $\psi(3686)$ and $J/\psi$ decays to $\chi_{c1,2}$, $b_{2}^{1}/b_{2}^{2} = 1.35\pm0.72$ and $a_{2}^{1}/a_{2}^{2} = 0.617\pm0.083$, which agree well with theoretical expectations. By considering the multipole contributions of $\chi_{c1,2}$, we measure the product branching fractions for the cascade decays $\psi(3686)\rightarrow\gamma\chi_{c0,1,2}\to\gamma\gamma J/\psi$ and search for the process $\eta_{c}(2S)\to\gamma J/\psi$ through $\psi(3686)\rightarrow\gamma\eta_{c}(2S)$. The product branching fraction for $\psi(3686)\rightarrow\gamma\chi_{c0}\to\gamma\gamma J/\psi$ is 3$\sigma$ larger than published measurements, while those of $\psi(3686)rightarrow\gamma\chi_{c1,2}\to\gamma\gamma J/\psi$ are consistent. No significant signal for the decay $\psi(3686)\to\gamma \eta_c(2S)\to\gamma \gamma J/\psi$ is observed, and the upper limit of the product branching fraction at the 90\% confidence level is determined.