Visual behavior characteristics of historical landscapes based on eye-tracking technology

Shimeng Hao,Rui Hou,Jie Zhang,Yang Shi,Yisong Zhang,Chen Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13467581.2024.2306361

IF: 0.904

2024-04-04

Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering

Abstract:The subjective encounter with architecture encompasses the particular presentation of architectural elements or the overall structure to individuals, taking into account their perception, cognition, and thought processes. The purpose of this research is to investigate the intricate relationship between visual attention directed towards historical architecture and the subjective experiences engendered during the process of observation. Utilizing eye-tracking technology within the realm of virtual reality, this study delves into the observation patterns exhibited by individuals when confronted with historical architecture, specifically focusing on the traditional courtyard residences found in Beijing's hutongs. The panoramic images, meticulously modeled and rendered, are divided into six distinct areas of interest: base, ground, window&doors, walls, roof, and eaves. The eye-tracking data of 81 participants, who engaged with 10 virtual scenes through the employment of VR headsets, along with their responses to architectural style questionnaires, were systematically gathered. Through comprehensive analysis, encompassing the examination of total fixation duration (TFD), fixation count (FC), first fixation duration (FFD), and time to first fixation (TFF) across the areas of interest (AOIs), in addition to deviations in scores among different architectural areas and styles, notable insights emerged. Results indicate that both professionals and non-professionals allocate heightened attention, as evidenced by TFD, FC, TFF, and FFD, to elements that exhibit greater score deviations in the questionnaires as opposed to those with smaller discrepancies. Moreover, the TFD and FC metrics pertaining to the Windows&doors AOI collectively constitute 40.20% and 40.71%, respectively. Undoubtedly, these figures signify the preeminent focal points within all AOIs. This underscores the pivotal role played by doors and windows in shaping individuals' judgments pertaining to historical architectural styles. This research provides designers with valuable understanding of the cognitive patterns exhibited by individuals in engaging with aspects of history, which enable them to identify and preserve key elements associated with historical styles. Additionally, it establishes a fundamental cornerstone for future quantitative research endeavors centered around the preservation of historical architectural styles.

construction & building technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to investigate the relationship between visual attention and people's evaluation of historical and non-historical architectural elements. Specifically, the study focuses on traditional courtyard houses in Beijing's hutongs, utilizing eye-tracking technology and virtual reality (VR) technology to quantitatively analyze observers' visual attention patterns. By collecting participants' eye movement data and their subjective evaluations of architectural styles through questionnaires, the researchers hope to understand which elements are more likely to attract attention and further explore the significance of these visual attention patterns for the preservation of historical buildings.

### Main Findings
- The study results show that both professionals and non-professionals tend to allocate more attention to elements with larger score differences in the questionnaire, rather than those with more consistent scores.
- Among all areas of interest (AOIs), the total fixation time and fixation count on doors and windows accounted for 40.20% and 40.71%, respectively, indicating that doors and windows are important focal points for judging historical architectural styles.
- These findings provide valuable cognitive pattern information for designers, enabling them to better identify and protect key elements related to historical styles, and lay the foundation for future quantitative research on the preservation of historical architectural styles.