Abstract:To address severe air pollution, the Chinese government plans to replace most residential coal stoves in northern China with clean heating devices by 2021. Coal stove replacement started in the “Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (BTH)” region and is expanding throughout northern China. Removing coal stoves reduces air pollutant emissions and hence is beneficial for both air quality and public health, as well as offering greenhouse gas mitigation co-benefits. However, there is little discussion of the economic costs of various clean heating technologies. In this study, we estimate total annual costs (TAC, annualized capital costs plus annual operating costs) for rural households, across cities/counties in the BTH region, to replace their coal stoves with several prevalent clean options—air-source heat pumps with fan coils (ASHPwF), electric resistance heaters with thermal storage (RHwTS), natural gas heaters (NGH), and clean coal briquettes with improved stoves (CCIS). We find: 1) Without subsidies, CCIS have the lowest TAC of all clean options. TAC of unsubsidized CCIS approximately doubles TAC of raw coal with improved stoves (RCIS), while unsubsidized electric/gas heaters cost 3–5 times more than RCIS. Thus, it is important for governments to financially support households' replacement of their coal stoves with clean heaters to facilitate widespread adoption. 2) With subsidies, CCIS have the lowest TAC in all regions except Beijing. In Beijing, generous subsides make ASHPwF—the most energy-efficient option—have the lowest TAC. In Tianjin, TAC of subsidized ASHPwF are slightly higher than CCIS and NGH. Throughout Hebei, except for a few severely cold northern counties where gas prices are high, subsidized NGH have lower TAC than ASHPwF and RHwTS. 3) Cost competitiveness of ASHPwF increases as heat demand increases, (e.g., higher desired indoor temperatures, larger home sizes, etc.) indicating that ASHP are good options for households with larger home sizes and commercial buildings. 4) Substantial potential exists to reduce heating expenses by improving building energy efficiency particularly in severely cold regions. 5) Cost advantages of NGH vary sharply with gas prices.

On the evaluation of the "coal-to-gas" project in China: A life cycle cost analysis

Integrated assessment of the environmental and economic effects of “coal-to-gas conversion” project in rural areas of northern China

Life Cycle Assessment of Residential Heating Systems: A Comparison of Distributed and Centralized Systems

Environmental and Economic Impacts of Transitioning to Cleaner Heating in Northern China

Life cycle impact of winter heating in rural China from the perspective of environment, economy, and user experience

Investigation On Life-Cycle Cost Of Coal-Based Synthetic Natural Gas (Sng)

Costs of Clean Heating in China: Evidence from Rural Households in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei Region

Revisiting energy transition projects future with "coal-to-gas" energy projects: assessing through life-cycle project cost method

Life Cycle Cost Analysis of Coal-Fired Power Generation and Its Alternatives

Field-based Measurements of Natural Gas Burning in Domestic Wall-Mounted Gas Stove and Estimates of Climate, Health and Economic Benefits in Rural Baoding and Langfang Regions of Northern China

Environmental benefits and household costs of clean heating options in northern China

Subsidies, Clean Heating Choices, and Policy Costs: Evidence from Rural Households in Northern China

Coal-to-gas heating compensation standard and willingness to make clean energy choices in typical rural areas of northern China

Climate Impact of Coal-to-clean-energy Shift Policies in Rural Northern China

Research on the Costs Analysis of Several Kinds of Heating Equipments Based on Whole Life Cycle

Will China's household coal replacement policies pay off: A cost-benefit analysis from an environmental and health perspective

Cost–Benefit Analysis of the China's Household Coal-to-Electricity Transition: A Case Study on the Beijing Mentougou Area

China’s Cap on Coal and the Efficiency of Local Interventions: A Benefit-Cost Analysis of Phasing out Coal in Power Plants and in Households in Beijing

Life Cycle Assessment and Environmental Cost Accounting of Coal-Fired Power Generation in China

Estimating the Environmental Efficiency and Marginal CO2 Abatement Cost of Coal-Fired Power Plants in China

Natural Gas and Electricity: Two Perspective Technologies of Substituting Coal‐burning Stoves for Rural Heating and Cooking in Hebei Province of China