Physical Robots in Education: A Systematic Review Based on the Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge Framework

Huayi Wang,Ningfeng Luo,Tong Zhou,Shuai Yang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16124987
IF: 3.9
2024-06-12
Sustainability
Abstract:Driven by the wave of artificial intelligence, the educational practice and application of robots have become increasingly common. Despite extensive coverage in the literature on various aspects of educational robots, there are still unexplored avenues, particularly regarding robotic support, robotic personality, and challenges in their applications. This study presented a systematic review of high-quality empirical research on the use of physical robots in educational settings. A total of 92 relevant papers from the Web of Science database were analyzed. Employing the technological pedagogical content knowledge (TPCK) framework, we investigated research questions across seven components, including the learning domain, teaching strategy, robot types, learning results, problems with using robots, robotic support, and robotic personality. The findings revealed that robots are most prevalently employed in language learning applications. When opting for teaching strategies, educators tend to favor those that incorporate physical interaction. Concurrently, humanoid robots emerge as the preferred choice among many. These robots, in human–robot interaction scenarios, often exhibit an agreeable personality. In terms of evaluating learning results, cognitive aspects like thinking, creativity, self-regulation, and inquiry ability are especially emphasized. Such results are frequently influenced by the informational and emotional support provided by robots. Nonetheless, challenges encountered by teachers, learners, and robots in this process are not to be overlooked. The findings of this study contributed to future applications of robotics in education.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problems that this paper attempts to solve include: 1. **Robotic Support**: Explore various functions and aids that robots can provide in educational environments, in order to better support diverse learning goals, enhance the effectiveness of human - robot interaction, and provide more personalized and valuable user experiences. 2. **Robotic Personality**: Research the personality characteristics of robots, especially those robots that can simulate human traits and behaviors. Understanding these personality characteristics helps to design more amiable and effective robots, thereby establishing unique emotional connections with learners. 3. **Challenges in Application**: Evaluate the problems encountered by teachers, learners, and robots in actual teaching. These problems not only involve practical operational difficulties at the technical level, but also include broader factors such as ethical considerations and social impacts. Specifically, based on the Technological - Pedagogical Content Knowledge framework (TPCK), this research systematically reviews 92 high - quality empirical studies, covering the following aspects: - **Learning Domain**: Explore in which subject areas robots are applied in education. - **Teaching Strategy**: Analyze the teaching methods adopted when using robots for teaching. - **Robot Types**: Classify and summarize different types of robots and their application situations in education. - **Learning Results**: Evaluate the cognitive, behavioral, and emotional learning outcomes of robots in education. - **Problems with Using Robots**: Identify and analyze various problems encountered in practical applications. - **Robotic Support**: Describe in detail the information and emotional support provided by robots in the educational process. - **Robotic Personality**: Research the personality characteristics of robots and their impacts on educational interactions. By delving into these under - researched areas, this research aims to provide a more detailed understanding for the future development and application of educational robots, and promote their integration and effectiveness improvement in different learning environments.