Video-assisted Thoracoscopic Surgery for Solitary Pulmonary Nodules in Patients with History of Primary Extrapulmonary Malignant Tumor: Analysis on 54 Cases
Yang Desong,Liu Yanguo,Jiang Guanchao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-6604.2012.03.001
2012-01-01
Abstract:Objective To analyze the clinicopathological characteristics of solitary pulmonary nodules(SPN) in patients with primary extrapulmonary malignant tumor,and to evaluate the value of video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery(VATS) in the diagnosis and treatment of the patients. Methods A total of 54 cases of SPN with history of primary extrapulmonary malignant tumor,who were treated by VATS in our hospital from January 2000 to August 2011,were enrolled to this study.We retrospectively analyzed the clinical characteristics,including age,gender,symptoms,disease-free interval between extrapulmonary malignancy and diagnosis of lung nodules,CT morphological characteristics of SPN,the operation information,and postoperative pathohistological characteristics.Results The procedures included wedge resection(n=36),segmentectomy(n=1),and lobotomy(n=17).Definitive histologic diagnosis included 36 metastatic tumors(66.7%),11 primary lung cancers(20.4%),7 benign nodules(13.0%).Two patients were converted to open surgery.No patients died perioperatively.In the patients with primary lung cancer,7 were in stage Ⅰ(63.6%),2 stage Ⅱ(18.2%),and 2 stage Ⅲ(18.2%).In the patients with primary lung cancer,the disease-free interval between extrapulmonary malignancy and diagnosis of lung nodules ranged from 13 to 276 months with a median of 84 months,which was significantly longer than that in patients with metastatic tumor ranged from 0.8 to 264 months(median,18.5 months;Z=-3.358,P=0.001).In the patients with metastatic tumor,CT examination showed spiculesign in 27.8% of them(10/36),lobulation in 38.9%(14/36),and pleural traction in 11.1%(4/36).And in the patients with primary lung cancer,CT examination clearly showed the edge of the tumor in 2 of the 11 cases(18.2%).Patients with history of colorectal carcinoma or bone and soft tissue sarcinoma showed significantly higher rate of metastatic tumor than the patients with histories of other tumors [90.9%(30/33) vs.28.6%(6/21),χ2=22.442,P=0.000].Those whose history of head/neck tumors(3/4),renal carcinomas(2/4),and breast cancer(2/4) tended to have primary lung cancer. Conclusions Close to 30% of SPN patients with primary extrapulmonary malignant tumor tend to be misdiagnosed by CT.Around 1/3 of the patients are proved to be primary lung cancer or benign nodules.VATS is a good choice for such patients.