Abstract:Forecasts of El Niño climate events are routinely provided and distributed, but the limits of El Niño predictability are still the subject of debate. Some recent studies suggest that the predictability is largely limited by the effects of high-frequency atmospheric ‘noise’, whereas others emphasize limitations arising from the growth of initial errors in model simulations. Here we present retrospective forecasts of the interannual climate fluctuations in the tropical Pacific Ocean for the period 1857 to 2003, using a coupled ocean–atmosphere model. The model successfully predicts all prominent El Niño events within this period at lead times of up to two years. Our analysis suggests that the evolution of El Niño is controlled to a larger degree by self-sustaining internal dynamics than by stochastic forcing. Model-based prediction of El Niño therefore depends more on the initial conditions than on unpredictable atmospheric noise. We conclude that throughout the past century, El Niño has been more predictable than previously envisaged. Present estimates of El Niño’s predictability are mostly based on retrospective predictions for the last two or three decades, encompassing a relatively small number of events. With so few degrees of freedom, the statistical significance of such estimates is questionable. In principle, predictability can also be estimated by perturbing initial conditions in numerical model experiments, but the answer is model dependent, and existing models have not been shown to be realistic enough for this purpose. El Niño is evident in instrumental observations dating back to the mid-nineteenth century and in proxy data sets over much longer periods, but no successful attempt to ‘hindcast’ the historic El Niño events before the mid-twentieth century has been reported. This is due partly to the lack of adequate data for model initialization and partly to the inability of present models to make effective use of available data. The study reported here represents the first (to our knowledge) retrospective forecast experiment spanning the past one-and-a-half centuries, using only reconstructed sea surface temperature (SST) data for model initialization. The intrinsic predictability of El Niño is surely limited, but there has been considerable debate about what the limitations really are. Classic theories consider El Niño and the Southern Oscillation (ENSO) as a self-sustaining interannual fluctuation in the tropical Pacific, being chaotic yet deterministic. Thus its predictability is largely limited by the growth of initial errors, and the potential forecast lead time is likely to be of the order of years. On the other hand, some recent studies emphasize the importance of atmospheric noise, particularly the so-called westerly wind bursts in the western equatorial Pacific. In such a scenario, ENSO is a damped oscillation sustained by stochastic forcing, and its predictability is more limited by noise than by initial errors. This implies that most El Niño events are essentially unpredictable at long lead times, because their development is often accompanied by high-frequency forcing. Such a view is not supported by the present findings. The observed and predicted SST anomalies averaged in the central equatorial Pacific are shown in Fig. 1a. (See Methods section

Thermodynamic Controls of the Atlantic Niño

Role of the Maritime Continent in the remote influence of Atlantic Niño on the Pacific

An Equatorial–Extratropical Dipole Structure of the Atlantic Niño

Distinct sources of dynamical predictability for two types of Atlantic Niño

Atlantic Warming Enhances the Influence of Atlantic Niño on ENSO

Tropical Atlantic variability in EC-EARTH: impact of the radiative forcing

The Role of Ocean Dynamical Thermostat in Delaying the El Niño–Like Response over the Equatorial Pacific to Climate Warming

Changes in interannual tropical Atlantic-Pacific basin interactions modulated by a South Atlantic cooling.

Multi‐Time Scale Variations in Atlantic Niño and a Relative Atlantic Niño Index

Sea surface temperature anomalies in the western Indian Ocean as a trigger for Atlantic Niño events

A Quantitative Explanation for the Large Impacts of El Niño During Its Decaying Stage

Distinct decadal modulation of Atlantic-Niño influence on ENSO

Atlantic Niño/Niña Prediction Skills in NMME Models

North Atlantic oscillation controls multidecadal changes in the North Tropical Atlantic−Pacific connection

El Niño/Southern Oscillation inhibited by submesoscale ocean eddies

A lower limit for atmospheric carbon dioxide levels 3 . 2 billion years ago

Dynamical and Thermodynamical Influences of the Maritime Continent on ENSO Evolution

Atmospheric Teleconnections of Tropical Atlantic Variability: Interhemispheric, Tropical–Extratropical, and Cross-Basin Interactions

Contrasting the Eastern Pacific El Niño and the Central Pacific El Niño: Process-Based Feedback Attribution

ENSO forced and local variability of North Tropical Atlantic SST: model simulations and biases

The Tropical Atlantic's Asymmetric Impact on the El Niño‐Southern Oscillation