The use and application of Lean Management methods to research processes--a scoping review protocol

Wraae,C. A. D.,Opstrup,N.,Kyvik,K. O.,Brixen,K.,Wien,C.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-074207
IF: 3.006
2024-05-16
BMJ Open
Abstract:Introduction Waste in medical research is a relatively well-known issue. However, only a few initiatives exist to address this issue. Lean Management methods (Lean) were developed in industrial manufacturing and later applied within healthcare improvement. Overall, the results from studies of the application of Lean to healthcare appear to be positive in terms of greater efficiency regarding treatment outcomes and patient care. Nevertheless, the application of Lean to improve research processes is not well studied and, given that research alongside clinical practice and experiential knowledge provides the foundation for the treatment and care of patients, it is paramount to identify approaches and review the degree to which they increase efficiency within research procedures. Therefore, this review will scope the landscape of studies that investigated Lean and how to implement Lean in research processes, particularly regarding healthcare research. Methods and analysis Our approach follows the methodological framework of Arksey and O'Malley for conducting scoping reviews (PRISMA-ScR). The search strategy for this scoping review was developed using the PCC model. We will identify the relevant literature by searching four search databases: Scopus, Web of Science, Academic Search Premier and Business Source Complete. Next, we will use citation pearl growing to identify all relevant published literature. The data charting process will follow the PRISMA-ScR checklist and will be organised using NVivo. We will generate qualitative and quantitative assessments of the extracted data by using NVivo, RStudio and Excel. We will follow the PRISMA-ScR guideline when reporting the results. Ethics and dissemination The review will comprise existing published studies and no primary data will be collected. Our findings will be shared through open access peer-reviewed journals, national and international conferences and emails to all relevant collaborative relationships. We plan to disseminate our findings via academic social media platforms, newspaper articles and blogposts.
medicine, general & internal
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the waste in medical research. Specifically, the author focuses on how to improve the efficiency of the research process and reduce unnecessary process components by introducing Lean Management methods. Although Lean Management has shown positive effects in industrial manufacturing and healthcare, its application in academic research, especially in medical research, has not been fully studied. Therefore, this review aims to explore the application and effects of process improvement models such as Lean Management in the academic research environment. ### Main problems 1. **Identify process improvement models applied to the research process**: What types of process improvement models are applied to the research process? 2. **Evaluate the effects of these models**: What impact do the implementation of these process improvement models have on the research process? 3. **Evaluate feasibility**: What are the advantages and disadvantages of implementing these models in the research process? ### Research background - **Waste in medical research**: It includes inefficiencies in data collection, analysis, and reporting, which is a well - known but not yet effectively solved problem. - **Application of Lean Management**: Initially used in industrial manufacturing and later applied in the healthcare field to improve work efficiency and patient care quality. - **Importance of research**: Research provides the basis for medical practice, so improving research efficiency is crucial for improving patient treatment and care. ### Research objectives The main purpose of this paper is to answer the following questions through a systematic literature review: - What have previous studies shown about the use and consequences of implementing process improvement models (such as Lean Management) in the academic research environment? ### Methods - **Literature search**: Use four databases, namely Scopus, Web of Science, Academic Search Premier, and Business Source Complete, for literature search. - **Screening criteria**: Only include peer - reviewed journal articles within the past 20 years, and these articles need to investigate the implementation and effects of any process improvement model in the academic research process. - **Data analysis**: Use NVivo, RStudio, and Excel for qualitative and quantitative analysis. ### Expected contributions - **Fill the research gap**: This is the first comprehensive review on the application of Lean Management in the research process. - **Provide practical guidance**: Provide specific improvement suggestions for research institutions to improve research efficiency and reduce waste. ### Possible limitations - **Time limit**: Only including literature from the past 20 years may miss some earlier related studies. - **Broad search terms**: The search terms used are relatively broad, which may lead to a time - consuming screening process. In conclusion, this paper aims to explore the application and effects of process improvement models such as Lean Management in academic research through a systematic review, thereby providing theoretical and practical support for improving research efficiency.