Abstract:We investigated carbon dioxide fluxes during a 13‐year permafrost warming experiment that caused differential subsidence and formation of thermokarst depressions. Some plots became inundated with water within thermokarst depressions, and others remained dry outside of thermokarst depressions. Permafrost thaw initially drove increasing rates of growing season carbon dioxide fluxes, but this trend reversed with significant spatial heterogeneity as thermokarst formed, with the net effect being greater carbon release. These findings indicate that Earth system models likely overestimate net growing season carbon uptake in abruptly thawing landscapes. Permafrost thaw causes the seasonally thawed active layer to deepen, causing the Arctic to shift toward carbon release as soil organic matter becomes susceptible to decomposition. Ground subsidence initiated by ice loss can cause these soils to collapse abruptly, rapidly shifting soil moisture as microtopography changes and also accelerating carbon and nutrient mobilization. The uncertainty of soil moisture trajectories during thaw makes it difficult to predict the role of abrupt thaw in suppressing or exacerbating carbon losses. In this study, we investigated the role of shifting soil moisture conditions on carbon dioxide fluxes during a 13‐year permafrost warming experiment that exhibited abrupt thaw. Warming deepened the active layer differentially across treatments, leading to variable rates of subsidence and formation of thermokarst depressions. In turn, differential subsidence caused a gradient of moisture conditions, with some plots becoming consistently inundated with water within thermokarst depressions and others exhibiting generally dry, but more variable soil moisture conditions outside of thermokarst depressions. Experimentally induced permafrost thaw initially drove increasing rates of growing season gross primary productivity (GPP), ecosystem respiration (Reco), and net ecosystem exchange (NEE) (higher carbon uptake), but the formation of thermokarst depressions began to reverse this trend with a high level of spatial heterogeneity. Plots that subsided at the slowest rate stayed relatively dry and supported higher CO2 fluxes throughout the 13‐year experiment, while plots that subsided very rapidly into the center of a thermokarst feature became consistently wet and experienced a rapid decline in growing season GPP, Reco, and NEE (lower carbon uptake or carbon release). These findings indicate that Earth system models, which do not simulate subsidence and often predict drier active layer conditions, likely overestimate net growing season carbon uptake in abruptly thawing landscapes.

Permafrost collapse after shrub removal shifts tundra ecosystem to a methane source

Permafrost collapse is accelerating carbon release

Tundra Soil Carbon is Vulnerable to Rapid Microbial Decomposition under Climate Warming

Permafrost and Climate Change: Carbon Cycle Feedbacks From the Warming Arctic

Permafrost carbon emissions in a changing Arctic

Permafrost collapse shifts alpine tundra to a carbon source but reduces N2O and CH4 release on the northern Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau

Abrupt permafrost thaw accelerates carbon dioxide and methane release at a tussock tundra site

Direct observation of permafrost degradation and rapid soil carbon loss in tundra

Long-Term Release of Carbon Dioxide from Arctic Tundra Ecosystems in Alaska

Exploring the interplay between soil thermal and hydrological changes and their impact on carbon fluxes in permafrost ecosystems

Contrasting above- and belowground organic matter decomposition and carbon and nitrogen dynamics in response to warming in High Arctic tundra

Rapid Ice‐Wedge Collapse and Permafrost Carbon Loss Triggered by Increased Snow Depth and Surface Runoff

Shrub expansion may reduce summer permafrost thaw in Siberian tundra

Effects of experimental fire in combination with climate warming on greenhouse gas fluxes in Arctic tundra soils

Warming-induced Permafrost Thaw Exacerbates Tundra Soil Carbon Decomposition Mediated by Microbial Community

Permafrost thaw driven changes in hydrology and vegetation cover increase trace gas emissions and climate forcing in Stordalen Mire from 1970 to 2014

Permafrost carbon−climate feedback is sensitive to deep soil carbon decomposability but not deep soil nitrogen dynamics

Carbon release through abrupt permafrost thaw

Tundra vegetation change and impacts on permafrost

Vulnerability of Permafrost Carbon to Climate Change: Implications for the Global Carbon Cycle

Abrupt permafrost thaw drives spatially heterogeneous soil moisture and carbon dioxide fluxes in upland tundra