Abstract:Objective To evaluate a "telephone first" approach, in which all patients wanting to see a general practitioner (GP) are asked to speak to a GP on the phone before being given an appointment for a face to face consultation.Design Time series and cross sectional analysis of routine healthcare data, data from national surveys, and primary survey data.Participants 147 general practices adopting the telephone first approach compared with a 10% random sample of other practices in England.Intervention Management support for workload planning and introduction of the telephone first approach provided by two commercial companies.Main outcome measures Number of consultations, total time consulting (59 telephone first practices, no controls). Patient experience (GP Patient Survey, telephone first practices plus controls). Use and costs of secondary care (hospital episode statistics, telephone first practices plus controls). The main analysis was intention to treat, with sensitivity analyses restricted to practices thought to be closely following the companies' protocols.Results After the introduction of the telephone first approach, face to face consultations decreased considerably (adjusted change within practices -38%, 95% confidence interval -45% to -29%; P<0.001). An average practice experienced a 12-fold increase in telephone consultations (1204%, 633% to 2290%; P<0.001). The average duration of both telephone and face to face consultations decreased, but there was an overall increase of 8% in the mean time spent consulting by GPs, albeit with large uncertainty on this estimate (95% confidence interval -1% to 17%; P=0.088). These average workload figures mask wide variation between practices, with some practices experiencing a substantial reduction in workload and others a large increase. Compared with other English practices in the national GP Patient Survey, in practices using the telephone first approach there was a large (20.0 percentage points, 95% confidence interval 18.2 to 21.9; P<0.001) improvement in length of time to be seen. In contrast, other scores on the GP Patient Survey were slightly more negative. Introduction of the telephone first approach was followed by a small (2.0%) increase in hospital admissions (95% confidence interval 1% to 3%; P=0.006), no initial change in emergency department attendance, but a small (2% per year) decrease in the subsequent rate of rise of emergency department attendance (1% to 3%; P=0.005). There was a small net increase in secondary care costs.Conclusions The telephone first approach shows that many problems in general practice can be dealt with over the phone. The approach does not suit all patients or practices and is not a panacea for meeting demand. There was no evidence to support claims that the approach would, on average, save costs or reduce use of secondary care.

Primary Care Telephone Triage Does Not Reduce Workload, Study Finds.

Evaluation of telephone first approach to demand management in English general practice: observational study

Effects of Telephone Consultation on Safety, Service Use, Patient Satisfaction, and Workload: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Trials

Are telephone-triage services less safe and efficient for managing unplanned care needs of older adults?

To what extent do callers follow the advice given by a non-emergency medical helpline (NHS 111): A retrospective cohort study

A randomized controlled trial evaluating the effects of nurse-led triage of 911 calls

A Primary Care Emergency Service Reduction Did Not Increase Office-Hour Service Use: A Longitudinal Follow-up Study

Tele-Triage Outcomes For Patients With Chest Pain: Comparing Physicians And Registered Nurses

Impact of an ABCDE team triage process combined with public guidance on the division of work in an emergency department

Factors affecting communication during telephone triage in medical call centres: a mixed methods systematic review

EXploring the journeys of Patients who End their Calls prior to Triage by NHS111: The EXPECT study

Patient compliance with NHS 111 advice: Analysis of adult call and ED attendance data 2013-2017

Evaluation of a pilot of a community virtual triage for breast symptoms outside of usual primary or secondary care pathways

Trends in clinical workload in UK primary care 2005-2019

Addressing challenges in telephone triage for outpatient oncology care: A data-centred digital routing solution.

Introducing a triage and Nurse on Call model in primary health care - a focus group study of health care staff's experiences

Outpatient chemotherapy: telephone triage for symptom management

Suitability of emergency department attenders to be assessed in primary care: survey of general practitioner agreement in a random sample of triage records analysed in a service evaluation project

A multinational survey of patient utilization of and value conveyed through virtual symptom triage and healthcare referral

How Healthcare Providers Decide on a Referral Location in Telephone Triage: A Cross-sectional Study

GP workload and patient safety