Observation of the Resonant Character of the $Z(4430)^-$ State

R. Aaij,B. Adeva,M. Adinolfi,A. Affolder,Z. Ajaltouni,J. Albrecht,F. Alessio,M. Alexander,S. Ali,G. Alkhazov,P. Alvarez Cartelle,A. A. Alves,S. Amato,S. Amerio,Y. Amhis,L. An,L. Anderlini,J. Anderson,R. Andreassen,M. Andreotti,J. E. Andrews,R. B. Appleby,O. Aquines Gutierrez,F. Archilli,A. Artamonov,M. Artuso,E. Aslanides,G. Auriemma,M. Baalouch,S. Bachmann,J. J. Back,A. Badalov,V. Balagura,W. Baldini,R. J. Barlow,C. Barschel,S. Barsuk,W. Barter,V. Batozskaya,Th. Bauer,A. Bay,L. Beaucourt,J. Beddow,F. Bedeschi,I. Bediaga,S. Belogurov,K. Belous,I. Belyaev,E. Ben-Haim,G. Bencivenni,S. Benson,J. Benton,A. Berezhnoy,R. Bernet,M. -O. Bettler,M. van Beuzekom,S. Bifani,T. Bird,A. Bizzeti,P. M. Bjornstad,T. Blake,F. Blanc,J. Blouw,S. Blusk,V. Bocci,A. Bondar,N. Bondar,W. Bonivento,S. Borghi,A. Borgia,M. Borsato,T. J. V. Bowcock,E. Bowen,C. Bozzi,T. Brambach,J. van den Brand,J. Bressieux,D. Brett,M. Britsch,T. Britton,J. Brodzicka,N. H. Brook,H. Brown,A. Bursche,G. Busetto,J. Buytaert,S. Cadeddu,R. Calabrese,M. Calvi,M. Calvo Gomez,A. Camboni,P. Campana,D. Campora Perez,A. Carbone,G. Carboni,R. Cardinale,A. Cardini,H. Carranza-Mejia,L. Carson,K. Carvalho Akiba,G. Casse,L. Cassina,L. Castillo Garcia,M. Cattaneo,Ch. Cauet,R. Cenci,M. Charles,Ph. Charpentier,S. Chen,S. -F. Cheung,N. Chiapolini,M. Chrzaszcz,K. Ciba,X. Cid Vidal,G. Ciezarek,P. E. L. Clarke,M. Clemencic,H. V. Cliff,J. Closier,V. Coco,J. Cogan,E. Cogneras,P. Collins,A. Comerma-Montells,A. Contu,A. Cook,M. Coombes,S. Coquereau,G. Corti,M. Corvo,I. Counts,B. Couturier,G. A. Cowan,D. C. Craik,M. Cruz Torres,S. Cunliffe,R. Currie,C. D'Ambrosio,J. Dalseno,P. David,P. N. Y. David,A. Davis,K. De Bruyn,S. De Capua,M. De Cian,J. M. De Miranda,L. De Paula,W. De Silva,P. De Simone,D. Decamp,M. Deckenhoff,L. Del Buono,N. Deleage,D. Derkach,O. Deschamps,F. Dettori,A. Di Canto,H. Dijkstra,S. Donleavy,F. Dordei,M. Dorigo,A. Dosil Suarez,D. Dossett,A. Dovbnya,G. Dujany,F. Dupertuis,P. Durante,R. Dzhelyadin,A. Dziurda,A. Dzyuba,S. Easo,U. Egede,V. Egorychev,S. Eidelman,S. Eisenhardt,U. Eitschberger,R. Ekelhof,L. Eklund,I. El Rifai,Ch. Elsasser,S. Ely,S. Esen,T. Evans,A. Falabella,C. Faerber,C. Farinelli,N. Farley,S. Farry,D. Ferguson,V. Fernandez Albor,F. Ferreira Rodrigues,M. Ferro-Luzzi,S. Filippov,M. Fiore,M. Fiorini,M. Firlej,C. Fitzpatrick,T. Fiutowski,M. Fontana,F. Fontanelli,R. Forty,O. Francisco,M. Frank,C. Frei,M. Frosini,J. Fu,E. Furfaro,A. Gallas Torreira,D. Galli,S. Gallorini,S. Gambetta,M. Gandelman,P. Gandini,Y. Gao,J. Garofoli,J. Garra Tico,L. Garrido,C. Gaspar,R. Gauld,L. Gavardi,E. Gersabeck,M. Gersabeck,T. Gershon,Ph. Ghez,A. Gianelle,S. Giani',V. Gibson,L. Giubega,V. V. Gligorov,C. Goebel,D. Golubkov,A. Golutvin,A. Gomes,H. Gordon,C. Gotti,M. Grabalosa Gandara,R. Graciani Diaz,L. A. Granado Cardoso,E. Grauges,G. Graziani,A. Grecu,E. Greening,S. Gregson,P. Griffith,L. Grillo,O. Gruenberg,B. Gui,E. Gushchin,Yu. Guz,T. Gys,C. Hadjivasiliou,G. Haefeli,C. Haen,S. C. Haines,S. Hall,B. Hamilton,T. Hampson,X. Han,S. Hansmann-Menzemer,N. Harnew,S. T. Harnew,J. Harrison,T. Hartmann,J. He,T. Head,V. Heijne,K. Hennessy,P. Henrard,L. Henry,J. A. Hernando Morata,E. van Herwijnen,M. Hess,A. Hicheur,D. Hill,M. Hoballah,C. Hombach,W. Hulsbergen,P. Hunt,N. Hussain,D. Hutchcroft,D. Hynds,M. Idzik,P. Ilten,R. Jacobsson,A. Jaeger,J. Jalocha,E. Jans,P. Jaton,A. Jawahery,M. Jezabek,F. Jing,M. John,D. Johnson,C. R. Jones,C. Joram,B. Jost,N. Jurik,M. Kaballo,S. Kandybei,W. Kanso,M. Karacson,T. M. Karbach,M. Kelsey,I. R. Kenyon,T. Ketel,B. Khanji,C. Khurewathanakul,S. Klaver,O. Kochebina,M. Kolpin,I. Komarov,R. F. Koopman,P. Koppenburg,M. Korolev,A. Kozlinskiy,L. Kravchuk,K. Kreplin,M. Kreps,G. Krocker,P. Krokovny,F. Kruse,M. Kucharczyk,V. Kudryavtsev,K. Kurek,T. Kvaratskheliya,V. N. La Thi,D. Lacarrere,G. Lafferty,A. Lai,D. Lambert,R. W. Lambert,E. Lanciotti,G. Lanfranchi,C. Langenbruch,B. Langhans,T. Latham,C. Lazzeroni,R. Le Gac,J. van Leerdam,J. -P. Lees,R. Lefevre,A. Leflat,J. Lefrancois,S. Leo,O. Leroy,T. Lesiak,B. Leverington,Y. Li,M. Liles,R. Lindner,C. Linn,F. Lionetto,B. Liu,G. Liu,S. Lohn,I. Longstaff,J. H. Lopes,N. Lopez-March,P. Lowdon,H. Lu,D. Lucchesi,H. Luo,A. Lupato,E. Luppi,O. Lupton,F. Machefert,I. V. Machikhiliyan,F. Maciuc,O. Maev,S. Malde,G. Manca,G. Mancinelli,M. Manzali,J. Maratas,J. F. Marchand,U. Marconi,C. Marin Benito,P. Marino,R. Maerki,J. Marks,G. Martellotti,A. Martens,A. Martin Sanchez,M. Martinelli,D. Martinez Santos,F. Martinez Vidal,D. Martins Tostes,A. Massafferri,R. Matev,Z. Mathe,C. Matteuzzi,A. Mazurov,M. McCann,J. McCarthy,A. McNab,R. McNulty,B. McSkelly,B. Meadows,F. Meier,M. Meissner,M. Merk,D. A. Milanes,M. -N. Minard,N. Moggi,J. Molina Rodriguez,S. Monteil,D. Moran,M. Morandin,P. Morawski,A. Morda,M. J. Morello,J. Moron,A. -B. Morris,R. Mountain,F. Muheim,K. Mueller,R. Muresan,M. Mussini,B. Muster,P. Naik,T. Nakada,R. Nandakumar,I. Nasteva,M. Needham,N. Neri,S. Neubert,N. Neufeld,M. Neuner,A. D. Nguyen,T. D. Nguyen,C. Nguyen-Mau,M. Nicol,V. Niess,R. Niet,N. Nikitin,T. Nikodem,A. Novoselov,A. Oblakowska-Mucha,V. Obraztsov,S. Oggero,S. Ogilvy,O. Okhrimenko,R. Oldeman,G. Onderwater,M. Orlandea,J. M. Otalora Goicochea,P. Owen,A. Oyanguren,B. K. Pal,A. Palano,F. Palombo,M. Palutan,J. Panman,A. Papanestis,M. Pappagallo,C. Parkes,C. J. Parkinson,G. Passaleva,G. D. Patel,M. Patel,C. Patrignani,A. Pazos Alvarez,A. Pearce,A. Pellegrino,M. Pepe Altarelli,S. Perazzini,E. Perez Trigo,P. Perret,M. Perrin-Terrin,L. Pescatore,E. Pesen,K. Petridis,A. Petrolini,E. Picatoste Olloqui,B. Pietrzyk,T. Pilar,D. Pinci,A. Pistone,S. Playfer,M. Plo Casasus,F. Polci,A. Poluektov,E. Polycarpo,A. Popov,D. Popov,B. Popovici,C. Potterat,A. Powell,J. Prisciandaro,A. Pritchard,C. Prouve,V. Pugatch,A. Puig Navarro,G. Punzi,W. Qian,B. Rachwal,J. H. Rademacker,B. Rakotomiaramanana,M. Rama,M. S. Rangel,I. Raniuk,N. Rauschmayr,G. Raven,S. Reichert,M. M. Reid,A. C. dos Reis,S. Ricciardi,A. Richards,M. Rihl,K. Rinnert,V. Rives Molina,D. A. Roa Romero,P. Robbe,A. B. Rodrigues,E. Rodrigues,P. Rodriguez Perez,S. Roiser,V. Romanovsky,A. Romero Vidal,M. Rotondo,J. Rouvinet,T. Ruf,F. Ruffini,H. Ruiz,P. Ruiz Valls,G. Sabatino,J. J. Saborido Silva,N. Sagidova,P. Sail,B. Saitta,V. Salustino Guimaraes,C. Sanchez Mayordomo,B. Sanmartin Sedes,R. Santacesaria,C. Santamarina Rios,E. Santovetti,M. Sapunov,A. Sarti,C. Satriano,A. Satta,M. Savrie,D. Savrina,M. Schiller,H. Schindler,M. Schlupp,M. Schmelling,B. Schmidt,O. Schneider,A. Schopper,M. -H. Schune,R. Schwemmer,B. Sciascia,A. Sciubba,M. Seco,A. Semennikov,K. Senderowska,I. Sepp,N. Serra,J. Serrano,L. Sestini,P. Seyfert,M. Shapkin,I. Shapoval,Y. Shcheglov,T. Shears,L. Shekhtman,V. Shevchenko,A. Shires,R. Silva Coutinho,G. Simi,M. Sirendi,N. Skidmore,T. Skwarnicki,N. A. Smith,E. Smith,J. Smith,M. Smith,H. Snoek,M. D. Sokoloff,F. J. P. Soler,F. Soomro,D. Souza,B. Souza De Paula,B. Spaan,A. Sparkes,F. Spinella,P. Spradlin,F. Stagni,S. Stahl,O. Steinkamp,O. Stenyakin,S. Stevenson,S. Stoica,S. Stone,B. Storaci,S. Stracka,M. Straticiuc,U. Straumann,R. Stroili,V. K. Subbiah,L. Sun,W. Sutcliffe,K. Swientek,S. Swientek,V. Syropoulos,M. Szczekowski,P. Szczypka,D. Szilard,T. Szumlak,S. T'Jampens,M. Teklishyn,G. Tellarini,F. Teubert,C. Thomas,E. Thomas,J. van Tilburg,V. Tisserand,M. Tobin,S. Tolk,L. Tomassetti,D. Tonelli,S. Topp-Joergensen,N. Torr,E. Tournefier,S. Tourneur,M. T. Tran,M. Tresch,A. Tsaregorodtsev,P. Tsopelas,N. Tuning,M. Ubeda Garcia,A. Ukleja,A. Ustyuzhanin,U. Uwer,V. Vagnoni,G. Valenti,A. Vallier,R. Vazquez Gomez,P. Vazquez Regueiro,C. Vazquez Sierra,S. Vecchi,J. J. Velthuis,M. Veltri,G. Veneziano,M. Vesterinen,B. Viaud,D. Vieira,M. Vieites Diaz,X. Vilasis-Cardona,A. Vollhardt,D. Volyanskyy,D. Voong,A. Vorobyev,V. Vorobyev,C. Voss,H. Voss,J. A. de Vries,R. Waldi,C. Wallace,R. Wallace,J. Walsh,S. Wandernoth,J. Wang,D. R. Ward,N. K. Watson,D. Websdale,M. Whitehead,J. Wicht,D. Wiedner,G. Wilkinson,M. P. Williams,M. Williams,F. F. Wilson,J. Wimberley,J. Wishahi,W. Wislicki,M. Witek,G. Wormser,S. A. Wotton,S. Wright,S. Wu,K. Wyllie,Y. Xie,Z. Xing,Z. Xu,Z. Yang,X. Yuan,O. Yushchenko,M. Zangoli,M. Zavertyaev,F. Zhang,L. Zhang,W. C. Zhang,Y. Zhang,A. Zhelezov,A. Zhokhov,L. Zhong,A. Zvyagin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.112.222002

IF: 8.6

2014-01-01

Physical Review Letters

Abstract:Resonant structures in $B^0\to\psi'\pi^-K^+$ decays are analyzed by performing a four-dimensional fit of the decay amplitude, using $pp$ collision data corresponding to $\rm 3 fb^{-1}$ collected with the LHCb detector. The data cannot be described with $K^+\pi^-$ resonances alone, which is confirmed with a model-independent approach. A highly significant $Z(4430)^-\to\psi'\pi^-$ component is required, thus confirming the existence of this state. The observed evolution of the $Z(4430)^-$ amplitude with the $\psi'\pi^-$ mass establishes the resonant nature of this particle. The mass and width measurements are substantially improved. The spin-parity is determined unambiguously to be $1^+$.