Low‐dose methotrexate therapy and hepatotoxicity
M. Korman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5694/j.1326-5377.1992.tb139720.x
1992-02-01
Abstract:Australian Family Physician in 1985. Sudden death in selenium-deflCient calves, at a similar age to that in SIDS infants (2-4 months), occurred soon after stress associated with feeding. This present letter provides some evidence from the literature about the possible biochemical derangement in selenium deficiency. In the absence of selenium-dependent enzymes such as glutathione peroxidase, there is a relative imbalance of "free radical scavengers". It is implied that levels of free radicals such as superoxide radicals are greater after "stress", although the mechanism is not clear to me, but seems to be contained in the unsubstantiated statement "The potential for the development of oxidant stress and reperfusion injury in cardiac muscle is limitless, as are the stated risk factors of SIDS." This statement requires ctarification. FitzHerbert quotes a recent paper of Lefer et aI. 3 in which myocardial damage (endothelial dysfunction) is characterised, in the isolated perfused cat heart, by a reduction in endothelium-derived relaxing factor. This is associated with reperfusion after myocardial ischaemia and is due to the generation of superoxide radicals. Scavengers such as superoxide dismutase and, it is presumed, also selenium-dependent enzymes, can protect against myocardial damage. Finally, FitzHerbert suggests (easons why infants may be nutritionally deficient in selenium. He cites evidence Qn a personal communication from PJ Healey, NSW Department of Agriculture, Veterinary Research Institute) that milk formulas in New South Wales may have low selenium levels, as may breast milk, the latter depending on the mother's dietary intake of selenium. It is noteworthy that formula-fed infants in Finland demonstrated the lowest serum selenium levels when compared with unsupplemented and supplemented breastfed infants.' Money, a veterinary surgeon in New Zealand, has emphasised the common pathological and epidemiological findings of SIDS and vitamin E/selenium responsive diseases of animals.' Two important conclusions which he made were: (i) the pathology of the animal diseases varies between species, according to the antioxidant needs of their tissues and the resulting location of tissue damage; and (ii) acute fatal disease is most frequent during the suckling period at two to three months, suggesting a transient deficiency that is corrected later by other food.· The hypothesis that SIDS may be related to selenium defiCiency, which remains subclinical unless "stress" is superimposed, is an attractive one. There are sufficient pathological and epidemiological features, as suggested by Money and FitzHerbert, to warrant testing this hypothesis. Preliminary data of selenium levels in heart muscles in six SIDS victims have been documented,' but no control data were provided and the small number studied limits interpretation. Lapin et aI.· examined hepatic trace elements, including selenium, in 13 subjects with SIDS and in 14 non-8IDS controls, and found no significant difference. However, liver may not be the target organ and unfortunately neither the heart nor other organs were examined for selenium levels. Furthermore, the ages of the controls were not given and may have been largely irrelevant, since the range was five days to 13 years. Rhead et aI. examined serum selenium and vitamin E levels in seven SIDS infants and found no difference to the previously published levels in nine full term and eight premature infants.' They concluded that circulating levels of selenium are low in early infancy compared with adults. Because of difficulty in obtaining suitable controls and the comparison of post-mortem selenium values with those in living infants they considered the data did not disprove Money's hypothesis. Preliminary findings of selenium deficiency and SIDS in Tasmania were recently provided at the Wanaka New Zealand SIDS Researchers Conference in 1991. FitzHerbert has drawn attention to one important hypothesis that may underlie some SIDS deaths. Animal models are readily available and physiological and pathological investigations are needed to explore the possible role of stress, such as a viral upper respiratory tract infection, in precipitating sudden death. The preliminary information in infants highlights the deficiencies in control data and the necessary national collaboration needed to obtain appropriate age-related control data. Heather Jeffery, MB BS, PhD, MRCP Staff Specialist Department of Perinatal Medicine King George V Hospital Camperdown, NSW 2050