Reply to Butler et al.: A sound hydrologic foundation for interdisciplinary studies of the High Plains Aquifer.

David R Steward,Paul J Bruss,Xiaoying Yang,Scott A Staggenborg,Stephen M Welch,Michael D Apley
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1323273111
2014-01-01
Abstract:i) Groundwater use rates continue: The letter states that “There is a systematic deviation (authors’ calculated use is increasing, whereas reported metered pumping data are decreasing)” and “is also markedly inconsistent with common experiences in western Kansas.” Yes, pumping rates decline as water tables fall. Yet, Butler et al. seem unaware of Kansas water use data served by the KGS’s Water Information Management and Analysis System portal (summed for counties in each agricultural district and plotted as red points in Fig. 1). It is clear …
What problem does this paper attempt to address?