Effects of Seating Location and Stereoscopic Display on Learning Outcomes in an Introductory Physical Geography Class
Daniel R. Hirmas,Terry Slocum,Alan F. Halfen,Travis White,Eric Zautner,Paul Atchley,Huan Liu,William C. Johnson,Stephen Egbert,Dave McDermott
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5408/12-362.1
2014-02-26
Journal of Geoscience Education
Abstract:Recently, the use of stereoscopic three-dimensional (3-D) projection displays has increased in geoscience education. One concern in employing 3-D projection systems in large lecture halls, however, is that the 3-D effect is reported to diminish with increased angle and distance from the stereoscopic display. The goal of this work was to study that effect in a classroom “real-world” lecture environment where such technology would actually be employed. Introductory physical geography concepts were taught to undergraduate students at the University of Kansas through a GeoWall (passive 3-D projection system) display with either static diagrams or interactive globe imagery (Google Earth). Student learning was gauged using both formative (in-class clicker questions) and summative (exam) assessments. We evaluated the spatial structure of students' formative and summative scores for two concepts: Earth–Sun geometries, taught with static images only, and arid landscapes and aeolian processes, taught with Google Earth only. Three significant results were observed: (1) students' ability to accurately observe the 3-D effect was not restricted to the recommended seating angles when using static images, (2) no spatial patterns of improved learning were observed when using static images only; and (3) a significant difference in learning was observed based on seating angles when using Google Earth. Although this study did not compare learning outcomes against a control group, as would be done in a tightly controlled experimental setting, our findings imply that seating angle should be considered in the design of a new classroom equipped with a stereoscopic display or when choosing an existing classroom to retrofit with this technology, particularly, if interactive, globe imagery, such as Google Earth, is used as a primary teaching tool.