Systematic Evaluation of Variability in ChIP-chip Experiments Using Predefined DNA Targets

David S. Johnson,Wei Li,D. Benjamin Gordon,Arindam Bhattacharjee,Bo Curry,Jayati Ghosh,Leonardo Brizuela,Jason S. Carroll,Myles Brown,Paul Flicek,Christoph M. Koch,Ian Dunham,Mark Bieda,Xiaoqin Xu,Peggy J. Farnham,Philipp Kapranov,David A. Nix,Thomas R. Gingeras,Xinmin Zhang,Heather Holster,Nan Jiang,Roland D. Green,Jun S. Song,Scott A. Mccuine,Elizabeth Anton,Loan Nguyen,Nathan D. Trinklein,Zhen Ye,Keith Ching,David Hawkins,Bing Ren,Peter C. Scacheri,Joel Rozowsky,Alexander Karpikov,Ghia Euskirchen,Sherman Weissman,Mark Gerstein,Michael Snyder,Annie Yang,Zarmik Moqtaderi,Heather Hirsch,Hennady P. Shulha,Yutao Fu,Zhiping Weng,Kevin Struhl,Richard M. Myers,Jason D. Lieb,X. Shirley Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/gr.7080508

2008-01-01

Abstract:The most widely used method for detecting genome-wide protein-DNA interactions is chromatin immunoprecipitation on tiling microarrays, commonly known as ChIP-chip. Here, we conducted the first objective analysis of tiling array platforms, amplification procedures, and signal detection algorithms in a simulated ChIP-chip experiment. Mixtures of human genomic DNA and "spike-ins" comprised of nearly 100 human sequences at various concentrations were hybridized to four tiling array platforms by eight independent groups. Blind to the number of spike-ins, their locations, and the range of concentrations, each group made predictions of the spike-in locations. We found that microarray platform choice is not the primary determinant of overall performance. In fact, variation in performance between labs, protocols, and algorithms within the same array platform was greater than the variation in performance between array platforms. However, each array platform had unique performance characteristics that varied with tiling resolution and the number of replicates, which have implications for cost versus detection power. Long oligonucleotide arrays were slightly more sensitive at detecting very low enrichment. On all platforms, simple sequence repeats and genome redundancy tended to result in false positives. LM-PCR and WGA, the most popular sample amplification techniques, reproduced relative enrichment levels with high fidelity. Performance among signal detection algorithms was heavily dependent on array platform. The spike-in DNA samples and the data presented here provide a stable benchmark against which future ChIP platforms, protocol improvements, and analysis methods can be evaluated.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Systematic Evaluation of Variability in ChIP-chip Experiments Using Predefined DNA Targets

Systematic evaluation of variability in ChIP-chip experiments using data

Diffreps: Detecting Differential Chromatin Modification Sites from ChIP-seq Data with Biological Replicates.

Systematic Evaluation of Factors Influencing ChIP-seq Fidelity

ChIP-chip versus ChIP-seq: Lessons for experimental design and data analysis

Optimization of experimental design parameters for high-throughput chromatin immunoprecipitation studies

COMPUTATIONAL ANALYSIS AND MODELING OF GENOME-SCALE AVIDITY DISTRIBUTION OF TRANSCRIPTION FACTOR BINDING SITES IN CHIP-PET EXPERIMENTS

Normalization and experimental design for ChIP-chip data

DiffChIPL: a differential peak analysis method for high-throughput sequencing data with biological replicates based on limma

ChIP-based methods for the identification of long-range chromatin interactions.

Detecting False Expression Signals in High-Density Oligonucleotide Arrays by an in Silico Approach.

Assessing the Performance of Different High-Density Tiling Microarray Strategies for Mapping Transcribed Regions of the Human Genome

A Genome‐wide, Promoter Tiling Design Scheme for High Quality Real‐time PCR Assays to Measure Genomic DNA in Chromatin Immunoprecipitation (chip) Samples

An Integrated Software System for Analyzing ChIP-chip and ChIP-seq Data

Computational Methodology for ChIP-seq Analysis

Letter to the editor: critical evaluation of the reliability of DNA methylation probes on the illumina MethylationEPIC v1.0 BeadChip microarrays

Unified Analysis of Multiple ChIP-Seq Datasets

Mapping of Transcription Factor Binding Regions in Mammalian Cells by ChIP: Comparison of Array- and Sequencing-Based Technologies

Qb-13006-xsl 54..70

Experimental and Computational Challenges from Array-Based to Sequence-Based Chip Techniques

DNA hybridization to mismatched templates: a chip study