Abstract:Fecal pollution of recreational waters can cause scenic blight and pose a threat to public health, resulting in beach advisories and closures. Fecal indicator bacteria (total and fecal coliforms, Escherichia coli, and enterococci), and alternative indicators of fecal pollution (Clostridium perfringens and bacteriophages) are routinely used in the assessment of sanitary quality of recreational waters. However, fecal indicator bacteria (FIB), and alternative indicators are found in the gastrointestinal tract of humans, and many other animals and therefore are considered general indicators of fecal pollution. As such, there is room for improvement in terms of their use for informing risk assessment and remediation strategies. Microbial source tracking (MST) genetic markers are closely associated with animal hosts and are used to identify fecal pollution sources. In this review, we examine 73 papers generated over 40 years that reported the relationship between at least one indicator and one pathogen group or species. Nearly half of the reports did not include statistical analysis, while the remainder were almost equally split between those that observed statistically significant relationships and those that did not. Statistical significance was reported less frequently in marine and brackish waters compared to freshwater, and the number of statistically significant relationships was considerably higher in freshwater (p < 0.0001). Overall, significant relationships were more commonly reported between FIB and pathogenic bacteria or protozoa, compared to pathogenic viruses (p: 0.0022⁻0.0005), and this was more pronounced in freshwater compared to marine. Statistically significant relationships were typically noted following wet weather events and at sites known to be impacted by recent fecal pollution. Among the studies that reported frequency of detection, FIB were detected most consistently, followed by alternative indicators. MST markers and the three pathogen groups were detected least frequently. This trend was mirrored by reported concentrations for each group of organisms (FIB > alternative indicators > MST markers > pathogens). Thus, while FIB, alternative indicators, and MST markers continue to be suitable indicators of fecal pollution, their relationship with waterborne pathogens, particularly viruses, is tenuous at best and influenced by many different factors such as frequency of detection, variable shedding rates, differential fate and transport characteristics, as well as a broad range of site-specific factors such as the potential for the presence of a complex mixture of multiple sources of fecal contamination and pathogens.

A Comparison of Rapid and Conventional Measures of Indicator Bacteria As Predictors of Waterborne Protozoan Pathogen Presence and Density

Influences of sample interference and interference controls on quantification of enterococci fecal indicator bacteria in surface water samples by the qPCR method

Rapidly Measured Indicators of Recreational Water Quality Are Predictive of Swimming-Associated Gastrointestinal Illness

Escherichia Coli and Enterococci Bacteria in Lake Michigan Beach Sand

Validity assessment of Michigan's proposed qPCR threshold value for rapid water-quality monitoring of E. coli contamination

Relationships between Microbial Indicators and Pathogens in Recreational Water Settings

Comparison of Cefotaxime-Resistant Escherichia coli and sul1 and intI1 by qPCR for Monitoring of Antibiotic Resistance of Wastewater, Surface Water, and Recycled Water

Same-day Enterococcus qPCR results of recreational water quality at two Toronto beaches provide added public health protection and reduced beach days lost

Two risk assessments: Evaluating the use of indicator HF183 Bacteroides versus pathogen measurements for modelling recreational illness risks in an urban watershed

Comparison of Ims-Free and Ims Real-Time Pcr Detection of Giardia Lamblia from Surface Water

Evaluation of Bacterial Pathogen Diversity,abundance and Health Risks in Urban Recreational Water by Amplicon Next-Generation Sequencing and Quantitative PCR

Spatial and Temporal Variation in Indicator Microbe Sampling is Influential in Beach Management Decisions.

Bacterial Community 16S rRNA Gene Sequencing Characterizes Riverine Microbial Impact on Lake Michigan

Comparison of Droplet Digital PCR and Real-Time Quantitative PCR for Quantitative Detection of the Parasitic Ciliate Ichthyophthirius Multifiliis in the Water Environment

Relationship between coliphage and Enterococcus at southern California beaches and implications for beach water quality management

Comparative decay of culturable faecal indicator bacteria, microbial source tracking marker genes, and enteric pathogens in laboratory microcosms that mimic a sub-tropical environment

Comparative detection and enumeration strengths of quantitative real-time PCR & FISH for waterborne bacterial pathogens in municipal wastewater

[Application of FCM-qPCR to Quantify the Common Water Pathogens].

High-throughput diagnosis of human pathogens and fecal contamination in marine recreational water

Distribution Comparison and Risk Assessment of Free-Floating and Particle-Attached Bacterial Pathogens in Urban Recreational Water: Implications for Water Quality Management

Site-specific risk-based threshold (RBT) concentrations for sewage-associated markers in estuarine swimming waters