Abstract:BACKGROUND:Replicate population pairs that diverge in response to similar selective regimes allow for an investigation of (a) whether phenotypic traits diverge in a similar and predictable fashion, (b) whether there is gradual variation in phenotypic divergence reflecting variation in the strength of natural selection among populations, (c) whether the extent of this divergence is correlated between multiple character suites (i.e., concerted evolution), and (d) whether gradual variation in phenotypic divergence predicts the degree of reproductive isolation, pointing towards a role for adaptation as a driver of (ecological) speciation. Here, we use poeciliid fishes of the genera Gambusia and Poecilia that have repeatedly evolved extremophile lineages able to tolerate high and sustained levels of toxic hydrogen sulfide (H2S) to answer these questions.RESULTS:We investigated evolutionary divergence in response to H2S in Gambusia spp. (and to a lesser extent Poecilia spp.) using a multivariate approach considering the interplay of life history, body shape, and population genetics (nuclear miscrosatellites to infer population genetic differentiation as a proxy for reproductive isolation). We uncovered both shared and unique patterns of evolution: most extremophile Gambusia predictably evolved larger heads and offspring size, matching a priori predictions for adaptation to sulfidic waters, while variation in adult life histories was idiosyncratic. When investigating patterns for both genera (Gambusia and Poecilia), we found that divergence in offspring-related life histories and body shape were positively correlated across populations, but evidence for individual-level associations between the two character suites was limited, suggesting that genetic linkage, developmental interdependencies, or pleiotropic effects do not explain patterns of concerted evolution. We further found that phenotypic divergence was positively correlated with both environmental H2S-concentration and neutral genetic differentiation (a proxy for gene flow).CONCLUSIONS:Our results suggest that higher toxicity exerts stronger selection, and that divergent selection appears to constrain gene flow, supporting a scenario of ecological speciation. Nonetheless, progress toward ecological speciation was variable, partially reflecting variation in the strength of divergent selection, highlighting the complexity of selective regimes even in natural systems that are seemingly governed by a single, strong selective agent.

Complementary Effect of Natural and Sexual Selection Against Immigrants Maintains Differentiation Between Locally Adapted Fish.

Natural and Sexual Selection Against Immigrants Maintains Differentiation among Micro-Allopatric Populations

Female Choice Undermines the Emergence of Strong Sexual Isolation Between Locally Adapted Populations of Atlantic Mollies (poecilia Mexicana)

GENETIC DIFFERENTIATION AND SELECTION AGAINST MIGRANTS IN EVOLUTIONARILY REPLICATED EXTREME ENVIRONMENTS

Intrasexual Competition Enhances Reproductive Isolation Between Locally Adapted Populations

Divergent Evolution of Male Aggressive Behaviour: Another Reproductive Isolation Barrier in Extremophile Poeciliid Fishes?

Gradient Evolution of Body Colouration in Surface- and Cave-Dwelling Poecilia Mexicana and the Role of Phenotype-Assortative Female Mate Choice

Extremophile Poeciliidae: Multivariate Insights into the Complexity of Speciation along Replicated Ecological Gradients

Toxic Hydrogen Sulfide and Dark Caves: Life-History Adaptations in a Livebearing Fish (poecilia Mexicana, Poeciliidae).

Extreme Habitats Are Not Refuges: Poeciliids Suffer from Increased Aerial Predation Risk in Sulphidic Southern Mexican Habitats

Toxic hydrogen sulfide and dark caves: phenotypic and genetic divergence across two abiotic environmental gradients in Poecilia mexicana.

Extreme environments and the origins of biodiversity: Adaptation and speciation in sulphide spring fishes

Toxic hydrogen sulphide and dark caves: pronounced male life-history divergence among locally adapted Poecilia mexicana (Poeciliidae).

The Rediscovery of a Long Described Species Reveals Additional Complexity in Speciation Patterns of Poeciliid Fishes in Sulfide Springs

Convergent life-history shifts: toxic environments result in big babies in two clades of poeciliids

The roles of inter- and intra-sexual selection in behavioral isolation between native and invasive pupfishes

Evolution in Extreme Environments: Replicated Phenotypic Differentiation in Livebearing Fish Inhabiting Sulfidic Springs

Invasive Fish Retain Plasticity of Naturally Selected, but Diverge in Sexually Selected Traits.

Unique evolutionary trajectories in repeated adaptation to hydrogen sulphide-toxic habitats of a neotropical fish (Poecilia mexicana).

Phenotypic Differentiation in a Heterogeneous Environment: Morphological and Life‐history Responses to Ecological Gradients in a Livebearing Fish

Locally Adapted Fish Populations Maintain Small-Scale Genetic Differentiation Despite Perturbation by a Catastrophic Flood Event