Reply To Liu: Amino Acid 104 Asparagine/Glutamic Acid Of P53 Is An Adaptively Selected Site For Extreme Environments In Mammals Of The Tibet Plateau

Yang Zhao,Ji-Long Ren,Ming-Yang Wang,Sheng-Ting Zhang,Yu Liu,Min Li,Yi-Bin Cao,Hu-Yue Zu,Xiao-Cheng Chen,Chung-I Wu,Eviatar Nevo,Xue-Qun Chen,Ji-Zeng Du
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1403299111
2014-01-01
Abstract:In our paper, we substantiate the fact that codon 104 variation is adaptive in highland Tibet plateau mammals (1). Liu’s letter (2) claims that codon 104 is not adaptive, which is only based on searching the sequence prediction in National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) without experimental evidence. Although the asparagine-104 (104N) also occurs in other lowland rodents, this does not mean that this mutation has occurred in the ancestors of rodents. In fact, among the rodents that Liu (2) mentions, all their p53 sequences, except mouse, rat, and gerbil, are based on prediction in NCBI. Notably, the fact that some other species other than rodents also carry 104N argues against the rodent ancestry of 104N. Codon 104 is believed to be adaptive because of its variation between two …
What problem does this paper attempt to address?