Abstract:Abstract A hallmark neuronal correlate of working memory (WM) is stimulus-selective spiking activity of neurons in prefrontal cortex (PFC) during mnemonic delays. These observations have motivated an influential computational modeling framework in which WM is supported by persistent activity. Recently this framework has been challenged by arguments that observed persistent activity may be an artifact of trial-averaging, which potentially masks high variability of delay activity at the single-trial level. In an alternative scenario, WM delay activity could be encoded in bursts of selective neuronal firing which occur intermittently across trials. However, this alternative proposal has not been tested on single-neuron spike-train data. Here, we developed a framework for addressing this issue by characterizing the trial-to-trial variability of neuronal spiking quantified by Fano factor (FF). By building a doubly stochastic Poisson spiking model, we first demonstrated that the burst-coding proposal implies a significant increase in FF positively correlated with firing rate, and thus loss of stability across trials during the delay. Simulation of spiking cortical circuit WM models further confirmed that FF is a sensitive measure that can well dissociate distinct WM mechanisms. We then tested these predictions on datasets of single-neuron recordings from macaque prefrontal cortex during three WM tasks. In sharp contrast to the burst-coding model predictions, we only found a small fraction of neurons showing increased WM-dependent burstiness, and stability across trials during delay was strengthened in empirical data. Therefore, reduced trial-to-trial variability during delay provides strong constraints on the contribution of single-neuron intermittent bursting to WM maintenance. Significance Statement There are diverging classes of theoretical models explaining how information is maintained in working memory by cortical circuits. In an influential model class, neurons fire exhibit persistent elevated memorandum-selective firing, whereas a recently developed class of burst-coding models suggests that persistent activity is an artifact of trial-averaging, and spiking is sparse in each single trial, subserved by brief intermittent bursts. However, this alternative picture has not been characterized or tested on empirical spike-train data. Here we combine mathematical analysis, computational model simulation and experimental data analysis to test empirically theses two classes of models and show that the trial-to-trial variability of empirical spike trains is not consistent with burst coding. These findings provide constraints for theoretical models of working memory.

Reply to Namboodiri and Hussain Shuler: Analysis of scaling of neuronal activities in medial prefrontal cortex during interval timing.

Representation of Interval Timing by Temporally Scalable Firing Patterns in Rat Prefrontal Cortex

Stable sequential dynamics in prefrontal cortex represents subjective estimation of time

The Fast Spiking Subpopulation of Striatal Neurons Coding for Temporal Cognition of Movements

Quantifying network behavior in the rat prefrontal cortex

Ramping cells in rodent mPFC encode time to past and future events via real Laplace transform

Ramping cells in the rodent medial prefrontal cortex encode time to past and future events via real Laplace transform

Cross-Frequency Coupling of Neuronal Oscillations During Cognition

Ramping single unit activity in the medial prefrontal cortex and ventral striatum reflects the onset of waiting but not imminent impulsive actions.

Sub-threshold neuronal activity and the dynamical regime of cerebral cortex

Temporal context modulates cross-modality time discrimination: Electrophysiological evidence for supramodal temporal representation

An fMRI Study Using a Combined Task of Interval Discrimination and Oddball Could Reveal Common Brain Circuits of Cognitive Change

Energy Consumption Optimization, Response Time Differences and Indicators in Cortical Working Memory Revealed by Nonequilibrium

Probing The Edge Of Synchronization: Cortical Activity Transiently Slips Into Slow Waves In Behaving Monkeys

Influence of Recent Trial History on Interval Timing

Investigation of frequency components embedded in EEG recordings underlying neuronal mechanism of cognitive control and attentional functions

Posterior Parietal Cortex Regulates Intrinsic Neural Timescales and Attentional Processing in Frontal Eye Field

Complementary cognitive roles for D2-MSNs and D1-MSNs during interval timing

Trial-to-trial variability of spiking delay activity in prefrontal cortex constrains burst-coding models of working memory

Frontal midline theta power during the cue-target-interval reflects increased cognitive effort in rewarded task-switching