Reply To Peters Et Al.: Further Discussions Confirm Early Holocene Chicken Domestication In Northern China

Hai Xiang,Jianqiang Gao,Baoquan Yu,Michael Hofreiter,Xingbo Zhao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1503956112
2015-01-01
Abstract:Peters et al. (1) raise several questions about early chicken domestication in northern China (2), including the claim that the climate would have been unsuitable for red jungle fowl. However, northern China was much warmer and more humid with much more extensive forest coverage during the early Holocene, as shown by the presence of buffalo bones (3) at Nanzhuagtou and macaque remains at Cishan (4), providing potential habitat for wild jungle fowl. We would also like to note that, in contrast to the claim by Peters et al., the data in reference 2 of ref. 1 indicate warmer conditions already during the early Holocene. Peters et al. also argue that, based on the …
What problem does this paper attempt to address?