Abstract:Monitoring crops with high spatio-temporal resolution satellites provides valuable observations to ensure food security in the global change context. This study focuses on estimating the Green Area Index (GAI) to monitor wheat crops with a spatial resolution of 3 m and daily satellite observations from the SuperDove constellation. With an easier access to large training datasets of ground GAI measurements, and the improvement of the realism of radiative transfer model simulations, the choice of the optimal approach (data-driven or model-driven) constitutes a key question when retrieving GAI from satellite observations. This study compares a data-driven and a model-driven approach to estimate GAI from the SuperDove satellites. Both approaches are based on Gaussian Process Regression (GPR) machine learning techniques. The data-driven approach uses over 300 ground GAI measurements collected from 12 sites in China and France, each with 20 to 51 contrasting plots. The model-driven approach uses 10,000 simulations of top of canopy reflectance and the corresponding GAI values generated by the LESS radiative transfer model applied to 3D scenes built with the ADEL-Wheat (Architectural model of Development based on L-systems) model. Results confirm that the SuperDove reflectance are reliable and consistent with Sentinel-2 values. When estimating GAI using GPR with SuperDove top of canopy reflectance, the model-driven approach (R2 = 0.83, RMSE = 0.80, Accuracy = 0.01 and Precision = 0.80) generally outperforms the data-driven approach (R2 = 0.80, RMSE = 0.88, Accuracy = −0.13 and Precision = 0.87), except for small GAI values. In-silico experiments show that the uncertainties in the ground-measured GAI and the size and diversity of the training datasets limit the data-driven approach. In contrast, the model-driven approach is mostly constrained by the realism of the reflectance simulations, particularly for low GAI values. Two ensemble solutions based on the weighted average of the two previous approaches are then proposed: the global ensemble solution (R2 = 0.86, RMSE = 0.75, A = −0.06 and P = 0.74) where the weight is assumed independent from the GAI values, and the adaptive ensemble solution (R2 = 0.85, RMSE = 0.76, A = −0.08 and P = 0.76) where the weight depends on the GAI values. Both solutions perform similarly, improving both data-driven and model-driven approaches. Finally, applying both solutions to monitor wheat plots along the growth cycle allows clear differentiation of nitrogen modalities and cultivar effects. However, a minimum plot size of 12 m × 12 m (4 × 4 pixels) is recommended to minimize the co-registration errors and increase estimate precision.

Monitoring crop growth inter-annual variability from MODIS time series: Performance comparison between crop specific green area index and current global leaf area index products

Non-Parametric Statistical Approaches for Leaf Area Index Estimation from Sentinel-2 Data: A Multi-Crop Assessment

Daily monitoring of Effective Green Area Index and Vegetation Chlorophyll Content from continuous acquisitions of a multi-band spectrometer over winter wheat

Comparing and combining data-driven and model-driven approaches to monitor wheat green area index with high spatio-temporal resolution satellites

How Universal Is the Relationship between Remotely Sensed Vegetation Indices and Crop Leaf Area Index? A Global Assessment

Modelling LAI, Surface Water and Carbon Fluxes at High-Resolution over France: Comparison of ISBA-A-gs and ORCHIDEE

Processing of remote sensing information to retrieve leaf area index in barley: a comparison of methods

Characterization and Intercomparison of Global Moderate Resolution Leaf Area Index (LAI) Products: Analysis of Climatologies and Theoretical Uncertainties

Assessing the Consistency of Crop Leaf Area Index Derived from Seasonal Sentinel-2 and Landsat 8 Imagery over Manitoba, Canada

Prototyping Sentinel-2 green LAI and brown LAI products for cropland monitoring

Assimilation of Global MODIS Leaf Area Index Retrievals Within a Terrestrial Biosphere Model

Estimation of crop gross primary production (GPP): II. Do scaled MODIS vegetation indices improve performance?

Exploring the Potential of Gaofen-1/6 for Crop Monitoring: Generating Daily Decametric-Resolution Leaf Area Index Time Series

Estimating Leaf Area Index of Winter Oilseed Rape Using High Spatial Resolution Satellite Data

Comparative Verification of Leaf Area Index Products for Different Grassland Types in Inner Mongolia, China

Forest and Crop Leaf Area Index Estimation Using Remote Sensing: Research Trends and Future Directions

Spatially and temporally continuous LAI datasets based on the mixed pixel decomposition method

Evaluation Of Land Surface Models In Reproducing Satellite-Derived Lai Over The High-Latitude Northern Hemisphere. Part I: Uncoupled Dgvms

A Novel Semi-Empirical Model for Crop Leaf Area Index Retrieval Using SAR Co- and Cross-Polarizations

Estimating Crop Biomass Using Leaf Area Index Derived from Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2 Data

A Photothermal Model of Leaf Area Index for Greenhouse Crops