A performance comparison of the meta model methods for discharge coefficient prediction of labyrinth weirs

Majedi-Asl,Amir Ghaderi,Mehdi Kouhdaragh,Tohid Omidpour Alavian,Mahdi Majedi-Asl
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.flowmeasinst.2024.102563
IF: 2.42
2024-02-24
Flow Measurement and Instrumentation
Abstract:Weirs are hydraulic structures with various applications, such as flow measurement, flow diverting, and/or flow control. Labyrinth weir as a nonlinear weir with a folded crest enhances the spillway system discharge capacity by increasing the crest length for a given channel width. As a remarkable parameter, the discharge coefficient plays an important role in determining weirs' passing capacity. So, it is important that the discharge coefficient be accurately represented to ensure an appropriate and economical design. This research evaluates the prediction accuracy of four soft computing techniques, such as support vector machines (SVM), gene expression programming (GEP), software (QNET), and artificial intelligence networks (ANN), to predict the discharge coefficient of labyrinth weirs using three different scenarios. The model's input parameters included the total water head ratio ( H T / P ), magnification ( L c / W ), and cycle wall angle ( α ). On reviewing the outcomes of the developed models, it appeared that each of them demonstrated satisfactory performance in predicting the discharge coefficient. However, ANN and SVM reveal more accuracy compared to other techniques. The prediction results reveal that the ANN as a superior model has the following performance metrics: R 2 = 0.998, DC coefficient = 0.996, and RMSE = 0.006. The sensitivity analysis results indicate that H T / P is the most effective factor in determining the labyrinth weir discharge coefficient in all methods. This suggests that the ratio of H T (total water head) to P (weir height) has a significant impact on the overall model performance. Upon comparing the results of this research with those of other researchers, it is evident that the evaluation indicators for all methods employed in this study are relatively superior.
engineering, mechanical,instruments & instrumentation
What problem does this paper attempt to address?