Abstract:Characterizing DNA methylation patterns is important for addressing key questions in evolutionary biology, geroscience, and medical genomics. While costs are decreasing, whole-genome DNA methylation profiling remains prohibitively expensive for most population-scale studies, creating a need for cost-effective, reduced representation approaches (i.e., assays that rely on microarrays, enzyme digests, or sequence capture to target a subset of the genome). Most common whole genome and reduced representation techniques rely on bisulfite conversion, which can damage DNA resulting in DNA loss and sequencing biases. Enzymatic methyl sequencing (EM-seq) was recently proposed to overcome these issues, but thorough benchmarking of EM-seq combined with cost-effective, reduced representation strategies has not yet been performed. To do so, we optimized Targeted Methylation Sequencing protocol (TMS)—which profiles ∼4 million CpG sites—for miniaturization, flexibility, and multispecies use at a cost of ∼$80. First, we tested modifications to increase throughput and reduce cost, including increasing multiplexing, decreasing DNA input, and using enzymatic rather than mechanical fragmentation to prepare DNA. Second, we compared our optimized TMS protocol to commonly used techniques, specifically the Infinium MethylationEPIC BeadChip (n=55 paired samples) and whole genome bisulfite sequencing (n=6 paired samples). In both cases, we found strong agreement between technologies (R² = 0.97 and 0.99, respectively). Third, we tested the optimized TMS protocol in three non-human primate species (rhesus macaques, geladas, and capuchins). We captured a high percentage (mean=77.1%) of targeted CpG sites and produced methylation level estimates that agreed with those generated from reduced representation bisulfite sequencing (R² = 0.98). Finally, we applied our protocol to profile age-associated DNA methylation variation in two subsistence-level populations—the Tsimane of lowland Bolivia and the Orang Asli of Peninsular Malaysia—and found age-methylation patterns that were strikingly similar to those reported in high income cohorts, despite known differences in age-health relationships between lifestyle contexts. Altogether, our optimized TMS protocol will enable cost-effective, population-scale studies of genome-wide DNA methylation levels across human and non-human primate species.

TAMeBS: A Sensitive Bisulfite-Sequencing Read Mapping Tool for DNA Methylation Analysis

Genome-scale sequence data processing and epigenetic analysis of DNA methylation]

A Comprehensive Evaluation of Alignment Software for Reduced Representation Bisulfite Sequencing Data

BatMeth: Improved Mapper for Bisulfite Sequencing Reads on DNA Methylation.

Single-base resolution analysis of active DNA demethylation using methylase-assisted bisulfite sequencing

BS-RNA: An efficient mapping and annotation tool for RNA bisulfite sequencing data

Objective and Comprehensive Evaluation of Bisulfite Short Read Mapping Tools.

Improving Bisulfite Short-Read Mapping Efficiency with Hairpin-Bisulfite Data

Investigating bisulfite short-read mapping failure with hairpin bisulfite sequencing data

A Bayesian Assignment Method for Ambiguous Bisulfite Short Reads

A Bayesian Framework to Identify Methylcytosines from High-Throughput Bisulfite Sequencing Data

Valibs: A Visual Aligner for Bisulfite Sequences

Enzymatic methyl sequencing detects DNA methylation at single-base resolution from picograms of DNA

Approaches for the Analysis and Interpretation of Whole-Genome Bisulfite Sequencing Data

Tet-mediated Covalent Labelling of 5-Methylcytosine for Its Genome-Wide Detection and Sequencing

A New Approach to Decode DNA Methylome and Genomic Variants Simultaneously from Double Strand Bisulfite Sequencing.

CpG_MPs: Identification of CpG Methylation Patterns of Genomic Regions from High-Throughput Bisulfite Sequencing Data

EPIC-TABSAT: analysis tool for targeted bisulfite sequencing experiments and array-based methylation studies

BayMeth: improved DNA methylation quantification for affinity capture sequencing data using a flexible Bayesian approach

Cost-effective solutions for high-throughput enzymatic DNA methylation sequencing

Benchmarking DNA Methylation Analysis of 14 Alignment Algorithms for Whole Genome Bisulfite Sequencing in Mammals