Abstract:This paper develops a chain-to-chain model that includes two manufacturers exhibiting scale diseconomies and two exclusive retailers under quantity competition. Firstly,we analyze the competition equilibrium of two supply chains under different vertical contracts( i. e. quantity discount contract and wholesale price contract). Secondly,we investigate the dominant equilibrium and the limitation of quantity discount contract that improve both manufacturer and retailer's performance by benchmarking the wholesale price contract. Lastly,we identify the dominant equilibrium and the limitation of quantity discount contract from the aspect of the whole supply chain's performance improvement.The results show that:( i) the intensity of manufacturer's scale diseconomies and the quantity competition between two supply chains often results in the adoption of quantity discount contract rather than the wholesale contract price. The quantity discount contract will improve the whole supply chain's performance regardless of whether the rival supply chain adopts the quantity discount contract. If the initial wholesale price is set in a proper interval at this time,the performance of both manufacturer and retailer will be improved.( ii) When quantity competition is relatively weak regardless of whether the intensity of manufacturer's scale diseconomies is strong or weak,or the quantity competition is relatively fierce and manufacturer's scale diseconomies are relatively strong,the quantity discount contract other than the wholesale contract price will create a dominant equilibrium for the whole supply chain. By setting the initial wholesale price in proper intervals at this time,the quantity discount contract will also produce a dominant equilibrium for manufacturer and retailer to improve performance.( iii) When both competing supply chains adopt the same vertical contract,manufacturer's scale diseconomies are relatively weak and quantity competition is relatively fierce,the wholesale price contract is better than the quantity discount contract for the manufacturer and retailer. This study extends the findings of McGuire Staelin's( 1983) study that for more highly competitive goods,manufacturers will be more likely to use a decentralized distribution system.

Equilibrium Structures of Two Supply Chains with Price and Displayed-Quantity Competition

Coordinating retailers with price and service competition

Study of the Competition of Location and Pricing between Two Supply Chains Each Consisting of One Manufacture and One Retailer

Chain-to-Chain Competition Under Demand Uncertainty

Equilibrium Analysis of Pricing Competition and Cooperation in Supply Chain with One Common Manufacturer and Duopoly Retailers

Competition decision models between supply chains under linear demand and asymmetric information*

Contract choice game of supply chain competition at both manufacturer and retailer levels

Information Structures and Pricing Decisions in Competing Supply Chains

Competition in Multi-Echelon Distributive Supply Chains with Linear Demand

Equilibrium Contracting Strategy under Supply Chain to Supply Chain Competition

Study of the horizontal competition of dual-channel retailer and traditional retailer with congestion negative effect of physical channel

Choice of Vertical Control Structure of Chain-to-chain Competition under Price Competition and Scale Diseconomies

Channel Coordination with Different Competitive Duopolistic Retail Behaviour and Non-Linear Demand Function

Two-echelon supply chain models: Considering duopolistic retailers’ different competitive behaviors

Selection of Supply Channel Based on Price Competition between Supply Chains

The Quantity Discount Contract of Chain-to-Chain Competition under Manufacturer's Scale Diseconomies

Equilibrium Contract Selection Strategy in Chain-To-Chain Competition with Demand Uncertainty

Optimal pricing policies for differentiated brands under different supply chain power structures

Equilibrium Analysis Of Distribution Channel Structures Under Power Imbalance And Asymmetric Information

Model of Asymmetric Cost Information Game among Multi-Supply Chains under Bertrand Competition Framework

Impact of pricing structure on supply chain coordination with cooperative advertising