Abstract:Model parameter inference is a universal problem across science. This challenge is particularly pronounced in developmental biology, where faithful mechanistic descriptions require spatial-stochastic models with numerous parameters, yet quantitative empirical data often lack sufficient granularity due to experimental limitations. Parameterizing such complex models thus necessitates methods that elaborate on classical Bayesian inference by incorporating notions of optimality and goal-orientation through low-dimensional objective functions that quantitatively capture the target behavior of the underlying system. In this study, we contrast two such inference workflows and apply them to biophysics-inspired spatial-stochastic models. Technically, both workflows are simulation-based inference (SBI) methods. The first method leverages a modern deep-learning technique known as sequential neural posterior estimation (SNPE), while the second is based on a classical optimization technique called simulated annealing (SA). We evaluate these workflows by inferring the parameters of two complementary models for the inner cell mass (ICM) lineage differentiation in the blastocyst-stage mouse embryo. This developmental biology system serves as a paradigmatic example of a highly robust and reproducible cell-fate proportioning process that self-organizes under strongly stochastic conditions, such as intrinsic biochemical noise and cell-cell signaling delays. Our results indicate that while both methods largely agree in their predictions, the modern SBI workflow provides substantially richer inferred distributions at an equivalent computational cost. We identify the computational scenarios that favor the modern SBI method over its classical counterpart. Finally, we propose a plausible approach to integrate these two methods, thereby synergistically exploiting their parameter space exploration capabilities.

Iterative improvement of parameter estimation for model migration by means of sequential experiments

Identification of nonlinearly parameterized nonlinear models: application to mass balance systems.

Bayesian improved model migration methodology for fast process modeling by incorporating prior information

Model Migration Through Bayesian Adjustments

Implementation of Parameter Estimation in Mechanistic Models by Dynamic Optimization

Generalized Parameter Estimation Method for Model-Based Real Time Optimization

Bayesian migration of Gaussian process regression for rapid process modeling and optimization

Cost-effective process modeling and optimization methodology assisted by robust migration techniques

Eliminating Ratio Bias for Gradient-based Simulated Parameter Estimation

Improving Parameter Estimation with an Efficient Sequential Probabilistic Collocation-Based Optimal Design Method

A Selective Migration-Based Improved GPR Modeling Method for Batch Process

Complex-valued Bayesian parameter estimation via Markov chain Monte Carlo

Model Migration with Inclusive Similarity for Development of a New Process Model

Parameter Estimation for Multivariate Nonlinear Stochastic Differential Equation Models: A Comparison Study

A Class of Hybrid Strategy to Estimate Model Parameters

Comparing AI versus Optimization Workflows for Simulation-Based Inference of Spatial-Stochastic Systems

An Adaptive Sequential Experiment Design Method for Model Validation

Scalable simulation-based inference for implicitly defined models using a metamodel for Monte Carlo log-likelihood estimator

A reinforced learning approach to optimal design under model uncertainty

Robust multi-stage model-based design of optimal experiments for nonlinear estimation

Estimation of Over-parameterized Models from an Auto-Modeling Perspective