Performances comparison of reverse osmosis and nanofiltration application to defluorination from groundwater: Influence factors and fouling analysis

Xiaowei Wang,Beidou Xi,Shouliang Huo,Wenjun Liu,Wenjun Sun,Desheng Li,Huibin Yu,Ma Weifang,Hongliang Liu

2011-01-01

Fresenius environmental bulletin

Abstract:Some bench-scale contrast experiments using the commercial reverse osmosis (RO) and negatively charged nanofiltration (NF) membranes on defluorination for the simulated groundwater were conducted. The aim of this study is to investigate the performance characteristics of RO/NF under different influence factors of feed groundwater (low salts). The membrane fouling was also analyzed to find an appropriate cleaning method. It was observed that the rejection efficiency order of ions is as follows: SO42- > Mg2+ > Ca2+ > F- > Cl- > NO3- > Na+ (for NF); and Mg2+ > Ca2+ > SO42- > F- > Na+ > Cl- > NO3- (for RO). The elements beneficial to human health with appropriate concentrations were retained in permeate by NF, e.g., F-, Ca2+ and Mg2+ etc., whereas most of them were removed by RO. The performances of NF were demonstrated to be more sensitive to influence factors of feed water. Significant changes of defluorination performances by RO/NF versus different feed pH-values were observed. Influenced by increasing water temperatures (10 - 32 degrees C), the defluorination rejection rate was decreased by 9% for NF but for RO only by 1%. The co-existing anions of Cl- and SO42- and humic acids impacted negatively on the defluorination efficiency of RO/NF, whereas the co-existing cations of Ca2+ enhanced the rejection. Therefore, the pretreatment processes, especially for NF, should be considered according to the feed groundwater conditions. The inorganic scaling formation in/on RO/NP membrane surfaces resulted in reduction of defluorination. The chemical cleaning could restore the RO/NP performances effectively, especially for NF.