Abstract:This paper developed a mixed multinomial probit (MMNP) model with alternative error specification and random coefficients (for both generic variables and personal attributes) to accommodate flexible covariance structure and taste variation. The MMNP model can be efficiently estimated with analytic approximations of multivariate normal cumulative distribution functions, which avoid defects of simulation-based integration in the mixed multinomial logit (MMNL) model. The integral dimension of the MMNL model increases as random coefficients increase, but it only depends on the number of available alternatives in the MMNP model. Simulation experiments and empirical analysis of Shanghai commuters' mode choice behavior were undertaken to examine the performance of MMNP models. Both simulation results and empirical results show that MMNP models can well accommodate flexible covariance structures and taste variation reflected through random coefficients being associated with both generic and personal variables. Empirical results indicate that the MMNP model performs better than traditional discrete choice models, such as the multinomial logit, the cross-nested logit, MMNL, and multinomial probit models. Random coefficients of "in-vehicle time of car" and "number of companions" indicate taste heterogeneity and the identifiability of random coefficients associated with both generic and personal attributes. Pairwise positive correlations between car/taxi, bus/metro, and bus/bus and metro are to be expected. However, the positive correlation between the car and metro modes may be unique to the Chinese city, Shanghai, because of the developed metro system. Unequal error variances reflect heterogeneities in unspecified factors in commute modes' utilities. The MMNP model will offer an alternative efficient way to accommodate taste heterogeneity and flexible error covariance structure in discrete choice models. Compared with the MMNL model, the MMNP model can accommodate more random coefficients without increasing computational complexity.

A Modified Paired Combinatorial Logit Route Choice Model with Probit-Based Equivalent Impedance

A Paired Combinatorial Logit Route Choice Model with Probit-Based Equivalent Impedance

A Modified Paired Combinatorial Logit Route Choice Model with Unified Parameter

Derivation, Implementation and Examination of Logit Route Choice Model with Relative Impedance

Modeling Stochastic Route Choice Behaviors with Equivalent Impedance

Modelling Travellers’ Route Choice Behaviours with the Concept of Equivalent Impedance

Modelling Stochastic Route Choice Behaviours with a Closed-Form Mixed Logit Model

A constrained multinomial Probit route choice model in the metro network: Formulation, estimation and application

Route choice modeling based on paired combinatorial logit model

Comparative Study of Logit and Weibit Model in Travel Mode Choice

Computation and Application of the Paired Combinatorial Logit Stochastic User Equilibrium Problem

Parameter estimation of logit route choice model with unified parameter

Modeling Elasticity, Similarity, Stochasticity, and Congestion in a Network Equilibrium Framework Using a Paired Combinatorial Weibit Choice Model

Research on the multiroute probit-based public transit assignment model based on bus stop

Considering En-Route Choices in Utility-Based Route Choice Modelling

A Subpath-Based Logit Model to Capture the Correlation of Routes

Mixed Multinomial Probit Model Accommodating Flexible Covariance Structure and Random Taste Variation: An Application to Commute Mode Choice Behavior

Algorithm of Random Network Flow Distribution Based on Multivariate Probit Model

Parameter Estimation of Stochastic Route Choice Model with Floating Car Data

A Physarum-Inspired Model For The Probit-Based Stochastic User Equilibrium Problem

A Multinomial Probit Analysis of Shanghai Commute Mode Choice