Abstract:Trajectory data has gained increasing attention in the transportation industry due to its capability of providing valuable spatiotemporal information. Recent advancements have introduced a new type of multi-model all-traffic trajectory data which provides high-frequency trajectories of various road users, including vehicles, pedestrians, and bicyclists. This data offers enhanced accuracy, higher frequency, and full detection penetration, making it ideal for microscopic traffic analysis. In this study, we compare and evaluate trajectory data collected from two prevalent roadside sensors: LiDAR and camera (computer vision). The comparison is conducted at the same intersection and over the same time period. Our findings reveal that current LiDAR-based trajectory data exhibits a broader detection range and is less affected by poor lighting conditions compared to computer vision-based data. Both sensors demonstrate acceptable performance for volume counting during daylight hours, but LiDAR-based data maintains more consistent accuracy at night, particularly in pedestrian counting. Furthermore, our analysis demonstrates that, after applying smoothing techniques, both LiDAR and computer vision systems accurately measure vehicle speeds, while vision-based data show greater fluctuations in pedestrian speed measurements. Overall, this study provides insights into the advantages and disadvantages of LiDAR-based and computer vision-based trajectory data, serving as a valuable reference for researchers, engineers, and other trajectory data users in selecting the most appropriate sensor for their specific needs.

Moving object trajectory processing based on multi-laser sensing

Trajectory analysis of moving objects at intersection based on laser-data

Online Multi-Object Tracking from A Bird's-Eye View by Fusion of Millimeter-Wave Radar and Vision

Detection and Tracking of Moving Objects at Intersections Using a Network of Laser Scanners

Pedestrian movement trajectory reappearance and crossing feature expression based on video processing

Evaluation of Roadside LiDAR-Based and Vision-Based Multi-Model All-Traffic Trajectory Data

Unsupervised Multi-Target Trajectory Detection, Learning And Analysis In Complicated Environments

Moving Object Classification Using Horizontal Laser Scan Data

Traffic Data Collection and Analysis for Intersection Using a Network of Laser Scanners

Online Multi-target Tracking for Pedestrian by Fusion of Millimeter Wave Radar and Vision

Vehicle Trajectory Collection Using On-Board Multi-Lidars for Driving Behavior Analysis

Multiple pedestrian tracking using LiDAR network in complex indoor scenarios

Combining Laser-Scanning Data and Images for Target Tracking and Scene Modeling

Omni-directional Detection and Tracking of On-Road Vehicles Using Multiple Horizontal Laser Scanners

Gps-Simulated Trajectory Detection

MTrajRec

A Laser-Scanner-Based Approach Toward Driving Safety and Traffic Data Collection

Novel Trajectory Optimization Algorithm of Vehicle-borne LiDAR Mobile Measurement System

A long-memory pedestrian target tracking algorithm incorporating spatiotemporal trajectory feature enhancement model

Moving object detection algorithm and motion capture based on 3D LiDAR

An Improved Object Detection and Trajectory Prediction Method for Traffic Conflicts Analysis