Abstract:BackgroundThe selection of the most accurate protein model from a set of alternatives is a crucial step in protein structure prediction both in template-based and ab initio approaches. Scoring functions have been developed which can either return a quality estimate for a single model or derive a score from the information contained in the ensemble of models for a given sequence. Local structural features occurring more frequently in the ensemble have a greater probability of being correct. Within the context of the CASP experiment, these so called consensus methods have been shown to perform considerably better in selecting good candidate models, but tend to fail if the best models are far from the dominant structural cluster. In this paper we show that model selection can be improved if both approaches are combined by pre-filtering the models used during the calculation of the structural consensus.ResultsOur recently published QMEAN composite scoring function has been improved by including an all-atom interaction potential term. The preliminary model ranking based on the new QMEAN score is used to select a subset of reliable models against which the structural consensus score is calculated. This scoring function called QMEANclust achieves a correlation coefficient of predicted quality score and GDT_TS of 0.9 averaged over the 98 CASP7 targets and perform significantly better in selecting good models from the ensemble of server models than any other groups participating in the quality estimation category of CASP7. Both scoring functions are also benchmarked on the MOULDER test set consisting of 20 target proteins each with 300 alternatives models generated by MODELLER. QMEAN outperforms all other tested scoring functions operating on individual models, while the consensus method QMEANclust only works properly on decoy sets containing a certain fraction of near-native conformations. We also present a local version of QMEAN for the per-residue estimation of model quality (QMEANlocal) and compare it to a new local consensus-based approach.ConclusionImproved model selection is obtained by using a composite scoring function operating on single models in order to enrich higher quality models which are subsequently used to calculate the structural consensus. The performance of consensus-based methods such as QMEANclust highly depends on the composition and quality of the model ensemble to be analysed. Therefore, performance estimates for consensus methods based on large meta-datasets (e.g. CASP) might overrate their applicability in more realistic modelling situations with smaller sets of models based on individual methods.

A New Method Based on Average Similarity for Predicting the Quality of the Predicted Models of Protein

Protein Model Quality Assessment by Learning-to-rank

A Method for Measuring Protein Structure Similarity Based on the Molecular Inner Spatial Density Distribution

A New Approach for Examining the Similarity of Protein 3D Shape

Three-dimensional protein shape similarity analysis based on hybrid features

A Similarity Computing Algorithm for Proteins

Protein single-model quality assessment by feature-based probability density functions

A Machine Learning-Based Method For Protein Global Model Quality Assessment

Evaluation of Protein Structural Models Using Random Forests

DeepQA: Improving the estimation of single protein model quality with deep belief networks

MQAPRank: Improved Global Protein Model Quality Assessment by Learning-to-rank.

MUfoldQA_G: High-accuracy protein model QA via retraining and transformation

How Good is Prediction of Protein Structural Class by the Component-Coupled Method?

Analysis and Compare of Methods Predicting Protein Complex

QMEANclust: estimation of protein model quality by combining a composite scoring function with structural density information

An unsupervised machine learning method for assessing quality of tandem mass spectra

A Sampling-Based Method for Ranking Protein Structural Models by Integrating Multiple Scores and Features

The Similarity For Prediction Of Signal Peptides Similarity

Improved estimation of model quality using predicted inter-residue distance

The similarity / dissimilarity analysis of protein sequence based on nucleotide triplet codon

A New Hybrid Model Of Amino Acid Substitution For Protein Functional Classification