Abstract:The development and application of coalescent methods are undergoing rapid changes. One little explored area that bears on the application of gene-tree-based coalescent methods to species tree estimation is gene informativeness. Here, we investigate the accuracy of these coalescent methods when genes have minimal phylogenetic information, including the implementation of the multilocus bootstrap approach. Using simulated DNA sequences, we demonstrate that genes with minimal phylogenetic information can produce unreliable gene trees (i.e., high error in gene tree estimation), which may in turn reduce the accuracy of species tree estimation using gene-tree-based coalescent methods. We demonstrate that this problem can be alleviated by sampling more genes, as is commonly done in large-scale phylogenomic analyses. This applies even when these genes are minimally informative. If gene tree estimation is biased, however, gene-tree-based coalescent analyses will produce inconsistent results, which cannot be remedied by increasing the number of genes. In this case, it is not the gene-tree-based coalescent methods that are flawed, but rather the input data (i.e., estimated gene trees). Along these lines, the commonly used program PhyML has a tendency to infer one particular bifurcating topology even though it is best represented as a polytomy. We additionally corroborate these findings by analyzing the 183-locus mammal data set assembled by McCormack et al. (2012) using ultra-conserved elements (UCEs) and flanking DNA. Lastly, we demonstrate that when employing the multilocus bootstrap approach on this 183-locus data set, there is no strong conflict between species trees estimated from concatenation and gene-tree-based coalescent analyses, as has been previously suggested by Gatesy and Springer (2014).

Phylogenomics Inference from Integrated Information

A Simple Method for Phylogenomic Inference Using the Information of Gene Content of Genomes

Investigation of Combining Plant Genotypic Values and Molecular Marker Information for Constructing Core Subsets

An information based sequence distance and its application to whole genome phylogeny

An Information-Based Sequence Distance and Its Application to Whole Mitochondrial Genome Phylogeny

Bioinformatics Approach for Molecular Evolution Research

A global test of hybrid ancestry from genome-scale data

Phylogeny Inference of Closely Related Bacterial Genomes: Combining the Features of Both Overlapping Genes and Collinear Genomic Regions

A Distance-Based Method for Inferring Phylogenetic Networks in the Presence of Incomplete Lineage Sorting

Phylogeny inference based on spectral graph clustering.

Large-scale k-mer-based analysis of the informational properties of genomes, comparative genomics and taxonomy

A New Distance Metric and Its Application in Phylogenetic Tree Construction

Genes with Minimal Phylogenetic Information Are Problematic for Coalescent Analyses when Gene Tree Estimation is Biased

Information Content of a Phylogenetic Tree in a Data Matrix

Genome-scale approaches to resolving incongruence in molecular phylogenies

Prokaryotic Phylogenies Inferred from Whole-Genome Sequence and Annotation Data

Estimating phylogenetic trees from genome-scale data

Species tree inference from genomic sequences using the log-det distance

Estimating Genome-wide Phylogenies Using Probabilistic Topic Modeling

Tree of Life Based on Genome Context Networks.

Data Requirement for Phylogenetic Inference from Multiple Loci: A New Distance Method