Abstract:In recent decades, short term traffic flow forecasting has been regarded as a critical aspect of developing the proactive traffic management and control systems. In this regard, many methods have been developed, and among these methods, artificial neural network (ANN) approach has been considered as a potentially plausible forecasting model for many transportation applications and has been investigated extensively over the decades. In the artificial neural networks, the learning process is an indispensable component for fine-tuning the model and hence to improve the prediction. However, the effects of training algorithms on the performance of ANN based short term traffic flow forecasting have not been adequately revealed. Therefore, in this end, the purpose of this paper is to compare the typical training algorithms that have been applied in the multi-layer perceptron (MLP) ANN model. In this paper, four typical training algorithms are selected for the MLP model, including gradient descent (GD), Levenberg-Marquardt (LM), Bayesian regularization (BR), and Fletcher-Reeves conjugate gradient (CGF). The forecasting performances were investigated using real world traffic flow data in terms of aggregated measures, disaggregated measures, and computation efficiency. The results show that in terms of forecasting accuracy, the models based on LM, BR, and CGF show similar performances and outperform the model based on GD. In terms of computation efficiency, the model based on BR method shows the best performance. Combined, ANN model based on BR can generate desirable short term traffic flow forecasting performances in terms of both accuracy and computation efficiency. Based on the study, future work is recommended on investigating or fine-tuning other well-known forecasting algorithms.

Overview of Traffic Flow Hybrid ANN Forecasting Algorithm Study

Short Term Traffic Flow Prediction Using Hybrid ARIMA and ANN Models

Traffic Flow Prediction Based on Hybrid ARIMA and ANN Model

Forecasting Approach for Short-term Traffic Flow Based on Principal Component Analysis and Combined Neural Network

Short-term Traffic Flow Prediction Using a Methodology Based on ARIMA and RBF-ANN

Artificial Neural Networks for Short Term Traffic Flow Forecasting: Effects of Training Algorithms

Traffic Flow Prediction Based on Adaptive Neuro-fuzzy Inference Systems

A Short-term Traffic Flow Forecasting Method Based on Combination of Fuzzy C-mean Clustering and Neural Network

A HYBRID SHORT-TERM TRAFFIC FLOW FORECASTING METHOD BASED ON NEURAL NETWORKS COMBINED WITH K-NEAREST NEIGHBOR

An adaptive hybrid model for short-term urban traffic flow prediction

Daily Long-Term Traffic Flow Forecasting Based on a Deep Neural Network

Short term traffic flow forecasting based on artificial neural network combined predictor

Short-Term Traffic Flow Prediction Considering Spatio-Temporal Correlation: A Hybrid Model Combing Type-2 Fuzzy C-Means and Artificial Neural Network

Hybrid Short-Term Traffic Forecasting Architecture and Mechanisms for Reservation-Based Cooperative ITS

Neural Network Optimized by Genetic Algorithm of Models for Real-Time Forecast of Traffic Flow

A hybrid autoregressive fractionally integrated moving average and nonlinear autoregressive neural network model for short-term traffic flow prediction

Short-term forecasting of traffic flow based on genetic algorithm and bp neural network

SHORT-TERM TRAFFIC FLOW PREDICTION USING A METHODOLOGY BASED ON AUTOREGRESSIVE INTEGRATED MOVING AVERAGE AND GENETIC PROGRAMMING

The Application of Nonparametric Regressive Algorithm for Short-Term Traffic Flow Forecast

Traffic Flow Prediction via Weighted Combination of ARIMA and WASDNN Models

A Survey of Hybrid Deep Learning Methods for Traffic Flow Prediction