Abstract:Macroscopic fundamental diagram (MFD) is widely applied in network modelling and management, such as route guidance and vehicle relocation, which are formulated as generalised dynamic traffic assignment (DTA) problems. MFD can effectively reduce the spatial dimension thus making the generalised DTA problems computationally efficient. In the literature, three MFD models, the accumulation-based model, the trip-based model, and the time delay model, were proposed to capture the traffic flow propagation under different traffic conditions and demand scenarios. However, no consensus has been reached on their computational efficiency and which model should be chosen under certain traffic conditions and demand scenarios. In this paper, we revisit these models regarding two important theoretical properties regarding flow propagation in the DTA, i.e. the first-in-first-out (FIFO) principle and causality. Corresponding dynamic network loading algorithms are designed to compare their numerical accuracy and computational efficiency. Numerical comparisons with Lighthill-Whitham-Richards (LWR) model and a micro simulator confirm that the accumulation-based model is valid in saturation, the trip-based model is valid in free-flow, while the time delay model provides a good approximation in both free-flow and saturation scenarios. On the other hand, violation of strict causality is observed in the accumulation-based and trip-based models, rendering it hard to pursue analytical DTA. This issue is not observed in the time delay model. Overall, the time delay model is a promising alternative for dynamic network loading in large-scale network applications.

Equilibrium analysis and comparison for general CTMs and LCTMs

Spatio-Temporal Evolution of Traffic Congestions on Urban Freeways

Location Specific Cell Transmission Model for Freeway Traffic

Anticipative and Adaptive Extension of Cell Transmission Model Based on Intelligent Transportation System Information

Network calculus based performance analysis of forces sctp tml in congestion avoidance stage

A Link Traffic Model by Incorporating Both Merits of Vertical and Horizontal Queue Concept

Incident-based Traffic Congestion Propagation Mechanism With Improved CTM Model

Research on Link Travel Time under Dynamic Inflow

Equivalent queue length model for congested traffic stream based on two-fluid theory

A new TCP/AQM system analysis

Modeling Mixed Bicycle Traffic Flow: A Comparative Study on the Cellular Automata Approach

Equivalent Queue Length Change Rate Models for Congested Traffic Flow

Cell-based Simulation and Estimation of Urban Traffic Network

Car-Following Theory of Steady-State Traffic Flow Using Time-To-Collision

A Novel Control-Oriented Cell Transmission Model Including Service Stations on Highways

Equilibria on a Congested Transportation Network

Alpha-reliable combined mean traffic equilibrium model with stochastic travel times

Modeling and Simulation of Traffic Congestion for Mixed Traffic Flow with Connected Automated Vehicles: A Cell Transmission Model Approach

A comparison of the accumulation-based, trip-based and time delay macroscopic fundamental diagram models

On the equivalence between continuum and car-following models of traffic flow

A Cellular Automaton Traffic Model by Mechanical Restriction and the Slow-to-start Rules in the Framework of Kerner’s Three-Phase Traffic Theory