On a conjecture on the tree with fourth greatest energy

Haiying Shan,Jiayu Shao,Shuchao Li,Xuechao Li
2010-01-01
Abstract:In [6], Ivan Gutman at al. conjectured that the tree P-n(2, 6, n - 9) of order n >= 14 has the fourth greatest energy among-all trees of order n. By using the method of "quasi-order <=", two of the present authors [8] claimed to have proved this conjecture by showing that T < P.(2, 6, n 9) for all trees T of order n with T is not an element of {P-n, P-n(2, 2, n - 5), P-n(2, 4, n - 7) P-n(2, 6, n-9)}, where P-n, P-n(2, 2, n - 5) and P-n(2, 4, n - 7) are known to be the trees of order n with the first, second and third greatest energies. In this paper, we show that the trees T-n(2, 2 vertical bar 2, 2) and P-n(2, 6, n - 9) are quasi-order incomparable, thus the above result T < P-n(2, 6, n-9) is not true for T = T-n(2, 2 vertical bar 2, 2). In this sense, the conjecture proposed in [6] has not been settled yet, and it cannot be settled by only using the quasi-order method.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?