SURVEY AND SUMMARY DNA nanotechnology assisted nanopore-based analysis
Taoli Ding,Jing Yang,Victor Pan,Nan Zhao,Zuhong Lu,Yonggang Ke,Cheng Zhang
2020-01-01
Abstract:Nanopore technology is a promising label-free detection method. However, challenges exist for its further application in sequencing, clinical diagnostics and ultra-sensitive single molecule detection. The development of DNA nanotechnology nonetheless provides possible solutions to current obstacles hindering nanopore sensing technologies. In this review, we summarize recent relevant research contributing to efforts for developing nanopore methods associated with DNA nanotechnology. For example, DNA carriers can capture specific targets at pre-designed sites and escort them from nanopores at suitable speeds, thereby greatly enhancing capability and resolution for the detection of specific target molecules. In addition, DNA origami structures can be constructed to fulfill various design specifications and one-pot assembly reactions, thus serving as functional nanopores. Moreover, based on DNA strand displacement, nanopores can also be utilized to characterize the outputs of DNA computing and to develop programmable smart diagnostic nanodevices. In summary, DNA assembly-based nanopore research can pave the way for the realization of impactful biological detection and diagnostic platforms via single-biomolecule analysis. INTRODUCTION As a new platform, nanopore technology presents various advantages over other detection modalities including low cost, high throughput and label-free sample analysis. Accordingly, nanopore analysis has been widely applied to fields such as gene sequencing, personalized medicine, biomedicine, food safety, environmental surveillance, and others. In particular, as a milestone for nanopore detection, in 1996, Deamer et al. proposed DNA sequencing using alpha hemolysin (1). In a typical nanopore experiment, two reservoirs are connected via a single nanometer-sized pore. Upon applying an electric field across the nanopore, electrically charged molecules are driven to translocate the nanopore via an electrophoretic force. When this occurs, conductive ions in the buffer are excluded from the nanopore, resulting in a measurable drop in current. Accordingly, biomolecules of various sizes and charges can be distinguished based on parameters of translocation such as dwell time and current drop amplitude (2). Inherently, nanopore experiments represent a single molecule detection method with ultra-sensitivity and high resolution, capable of discriminating minute differences among single nucleotide bases A, T, G and C. Compared with previous nanopore applications, which mainly focused on gene sequencing (3–6), recent nanopore technologies have also been extended to analyze the physical and chemical properties of various molecules (7) such as nucleic acids (8–12), proteins (13–18), nanoparticles (19–25) and ions (26–32). *To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel: +86 01062750359; Fax: +86 01062750359; Email: zhangcheng369@pku.edu.cn Correspondence may also be addressed to Zuhong Lu. Tel: +86 02583793110; Fax: +86 02583793110; Email: zhlu@seu.edu.cn Correspondence may also be addressed to Yonggang Ke. Tel: +1 404 712 2712; Fax: +1 404 712 2712; Email: yonggang.ke@emory.edu †The authors wish it to be known that, in their opinion, the second and third authors should be regarded as Joint Second Authors. C © The Author(s) 2020. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Nucleic Acids Research. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com D ow naded rom http/academ ic.p.com /nar/advance-articleoi/10.1093/nar/gkaa095/5742838 by gest on 26 Feruary 2020 2 Nucleic Acids Research, 2020 Based on materials, nanopores can be divided into two categories: biological nanopore (33) and solid-state nanopore (SS-nanopore) (Figure 1) (34). Biological nanopores comprise channel-bearing proteins such as Phi29 (35–37) and -hemolysin (38–44). With a narrow channel (general diameter 1 nm–2 nm), protein nanopores can produce sensitive and accurate electrical signals in DNA sequencing due to the similarities they share with the diameter of single-strand DNA (ssDNA). In addition, experimental repeatability is another advantage of biological nanopores, according to which selected portable commercial nanopore devices are being developed. However, issues must be considered when using biological nanopores. For example, it is not easy to readily modify protein nanopores, which limits the scope of their application. Moreover, proteins are more sensitive to external environmental conditions because small variations in temperature or pH will significantly affect biological nanopores’ conformation and activity. SS-nanopores are nanopores are constructed using abiotic materials (45,46). The straightforward fabrication procedures of SS nanopores render diameter control adjustable and scalable, which enables wider sensing ranges to encompass not only small molecules such as DNA, but also large protein targets. However, SS nanopore-based detection faces several challenges. First, the translocation velocity of analytes is generally too fast to allow for consistent identification of smaller biomolecules because of comparatively large nanopore diameters. To solve this problem, various methods including gel substrates (47), molecular modifications on the nanopore (48), blocking the pore with nanobeads (49), applying various high-salt buffers (50) are utilized. However, not all of these methods are satisfactory because of deficiencies such as increased experimental complexity, random systematic noise, and modification difficulties. Additionally, SS nanopore membranes are too thick to acquire high signal-to-noise ratios at a high resolution, compared with biological nanopores in DNA sequencing. In order to improve the resolution and sensitivity of SS nanopores, scientists have combined super-thin two-dimensional materials like molybdenum disulfide (4) and graphene with SS nanopores (51–55). Nevertheless, the preparation of two-dimensional material-based nanopores are complicated, inconvenient, and expensive. DNA nanotechnology focused on using DNA to construct various self-assembled structures was recently developed. As a versatile technology, DNA assembly is already applied to various nanopore-based analyses. For example, DNA self-assembly structures can be used to capture target biomolecules to form complex spatial arrangements (56), or to serve as possible channels for potential drug delivery (57). Importantly, DNA nanotechnology may also provide practical solutions to the aforementioned challenges in nanopore detection (34,58,59). Several efforts have been made to combine nanopore analysis and DNA nanotechnology in the past decade. For example, scientists directly used DNA nanotechnology to construct assembled nanopores performing target molecule nanopore translocation (60). Notably, in these studies, DNA nanotechnology endowed the nanopore platform with fine-tunable and adjustable properties. In this review article, we summarize research associating nanopore techniques with DNA nanotechnology. Several categories will be discussed to highlight recent studies combining DNA nanotechnology and nanopore detection. We will primarily discuss recent progress combining DNA nanotechnology and nanopore detection in the following categories: (i) DNA carrier-mediated escort of targets in nanopore translocation; (ii) DNA-assembled nanopores for singlemolecule detection with tunable and adjustable properties; (iii) nanopore detection of targets based on the dynamic control of DNA assembly. Combined with DNA nanotechnology, nanopore analysis methods have been greatly improved. To date, several studies have been conducted in this interdisciplinary field. Considering the universal applications of nanopore analysis combined with DNA nanotechnology, this review article highlights related works and inspired ideas to introduce this study area to researchers. Finally, we envision that the association of DNA nanotechnology and nanopores will create many new sensing methods for biodetection, nanoengineering, diagnostics and therapeutics.