Abstract:The two key steps for analyzing proteomic data generated by high-resolution MS are database searching and postprocessing. While the two steps are interrelated, studies on their combinatory effects and the optimization of these procedures have not been adequately conducted. Here, we investigated the performance of three popular search engines (SEQUEST, Mascot, and MS Amanda) in conjunction with five filtering approaches, including respective score-based filtering, a group-based approach, local false discovery rate (LFDR), PeptideProphet, and Percolator. A total of eight data sets from various proteomes (e.g., E. coli, yeast, and human) produced by various instruments with high-accuracy survey scan (MS1) and high- or low-accuracy fragment ion scan (MS2) (LTQ-Orbitrap, Orbitrap-Velos, Orbitrap-Elite, Q-Exactive, Orbitrap-Fusion, and Q-TOF) were analyzed. It was found combinations involving Percolator achieved markedly more peptide and protein identifications at the same FDR level than the other 12 combinations for all data sets. Among these, combinations of SEQUEST-Percolator and MS Amanda-Percolator provided slightly better performances for data sets with low-accuracy MS2 (ion trap or IT) and high accuracy MS2 (Orbitrap or TOF), respectively, than did other methods. For approaches without Percolator, SEQUEST-group performs the best for data sets with MS2 produced by collision-induced dissociation (CID) and IT analysis; Mascot-LFDR gives more identifications for data sets generated by higher-energy collisional dissociation (HCD) and analyzed in Orbitrap (HCD-OT) and in Orbitrap Fusion (HCD-IT); MS Amanda-Group excels for the Q-TOF data set and the Orbitrap Velos HCD-OT data set. Therefore, if Percolator was not used, a specific combination should be applied for each type of data set. Moreover, a higher percentage of multiple-peptide proteins and lower variation of protein spectral counts were observed when analyzing technical replicates using Percolator-associated combinations; therefore, Percolator enhanced the reliability for both identification and quantification. The analyses were performed using the specific programs embedded in Proteome Discoverer, Scaffold, and an in-house algorithm (BuildSummary). These results provide valuable guidelines for the optimal interpretation of proteomic results and the development of fit-for-purpose protocols under different situations.

Improved peptide identification for proteomic analysis based on comprehensive characterization of electron transfer dissociation spectra.

Improved proteomic analysis pipeline for LC-ETD-MS/MS using charge enhancing methods.

Better Score Function for Peptide Identification with ETD MS/MS Spectra

Statistical analysis of electron transfer dissociation pairwise fragmentation patterns.

Rapidly Alternating Transmission Mode Electron-Transfer Dissociation and Collisional Activation for the Characterization of Polypeptide Ions

Electron Transfer Dissociation (ETD) of Peptides Containing Intrachain Disulfide Bonds

PeaksDB: New Software for Substantially Improved Peptide Identification from Orbitrap ETD Mass Spectrometry

Peptide Sequence Analysis by Electron Transfer Dissociation Mass Spectrometry: A Web-Based Tutorial

Electron-Induced Dissociation of Peptides in a Triple Quadrupole Mass Spectrometer Retrofitted with an Electromagnetostatic Cell

Identification of Proteins and Phosphoproteins Using Pulsed Q Collision Induced Dissociation (PQD)

Electron-Activated Dissociation and Collision-Induced Dissociation Glycopeptide Fragmentation for Improved Glycoproteomics

Proteomics with Enhanced In-Source Fragmentation/Annotation: Applying XCMS-EISA Informatics and Q-MRM High-Sensitivity Quantification.

Efficient discovery of abundant post-translational modifications and spectral pairs using peptide mass and retention time differences

High-confidence De Novo Peptide Sequencing Using Positive Charge Derivatization and Tandem MS Spectra Merging.

Radical Cascades in Electron Transfer Dissociation (etd) - Implications for Characterizing Peptide Disulfide Regioisomers

Speeding up tandem mass spectrometry based database searching by peptide and spectrum indexing.

Influence of the Metals and Ligands in Dinuclear Complexes on Phosphopeptide Sequencing by Electron Transfer Dissociation Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Pnovo: De Novo Peptide Sequencing and Identification Using HCD Spectra.

Optimization of Search Engines and Postprocessing Approaches to Maximize Peptide and Protein Identification for High-Resolution Mass Data

PEAKS DB: De Novo Sequencing Assisted Database Search for Sensitive and Accurate Peptide Identification.

Structural Characterization of Native Proteins and Protein Complexes by Electron Ionization Dissociation-Mass Spectrometry.