Chinese projections of Thoreau and his Walden ’s influence in China

Jincai Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11059-009-0006-4

2009-01-01

Neohelicon

Abstract:In 1995, Walter Harding turned out an article titled “Thoreau’s Reputation” trying to render a picture of how Thoreau had been perceived in a world other than the United States. He mentioned in particular the translation of the writer into different languages such as German, Dutch, Russian, Japanese, French, Czechoslovakian and Italian and he specifically dwelled on the Japanese reception of Thoreau and his works, without a single word about the abundance of Chinese scholarship on the same writer. This essay begins with a critical survey of how Thoreau has been perceived in China. It argues that there are tentatively three different stages as regards the Chinese projections of Thoreau in terms of issues raised and handled. The first stage roughly from the 1920s to 1949 marks China’s burgeoning interest in the American writer featured by a passion for Western literature as both cultural and intellectual nourishment. The second is mainly a period of ideological appraisals from 1949 to 1977 in which Thoreau is regarded as a champion of democracy and a critic of American capitalist civilization. The third one is known as the multiple approach period from 1978 onwards in which Thoreau studies has flourished and continues to grow in China. Focused discussions have revealed the following: (1) comparative approaches have been made into the Chinese elements in the formation of Thoreau’s notion of civilization and views of Nature; (2) critical attention has been drawn on Thoreau’s political thought and ecological awareness, rendering a multitude of interpretations both textually and theoretically; and (3) further discussions focus primarily on Thoreau’s personal conduct raising a question of how to appraise Thoreau’s withdrawal from society and giving rise to an ambiguous identity of Thoreau. Intertwined in my discussion is a further exploration of Walden ’s influence in China and how Thoreau is integrated in contemporary Chinese writing at this age of ecological awareness.