A Comparative Study of Extracting Urban Vegetation Information by Vegetation Indices from Thematic Mapper Images
LUO Ya,XU Jian-hua,YUE Wen-ze,CHEN Wen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-0323.2006.03.008
2006-01-01
Abstract:As to technology and economic cost synthetically,extracting urban vegetation features by vegetation indices from Thematic Mapper(TM) images is a comparatively good way.Because of the particularity of the urban vegetation and varieties of vegetation indeices(VIs),Which vegetation index is suitable to discriminate urban vegetation features still remains a problem to be solved urgently.This study area is located in Shanghai.We utilize a combination of one-way ANOVA and multiple comparisons approaches to demonstrate the differences and similarities in sensitivity to vegetation conditions of the nine indices including NDVI,DVI,EVI,GEMI,GNDVI,RDVI,RVI,TGDVI and TNDVI.The analysis results indicate:①After TM images being managed by VIs,the vegetation information in TM images has really been enhanced.But their potential for discriminating vegetation of different VIs is not the same.Our result shows the performance and validity of discriminating vegetation of VIs is evaluated as follows: GEMI,RDVI,NDVI,GNDVI,RVI,TNDVI,DVI,EVI and TGDVI from excellent to bad.②VIs can extract vegetation features from TM images basically,however,can't do well in discriminate the vegetation in detail.In all,VIs can identify grass and farmland except EVI and TGDVI.EVI does better in discriminating grass and woods while GEMI is more suitable to distinguish grass and farmland.On discriminating woods and farmland TNDVI is a better choice.③VIs can identify neither vegetation nor non-vegetation further.On the whole,it is very difficult for all the vegetation indices to discriminate buildings and roads,specially for TGDVI,DVI and EVI.NDVI,GNDVI,TNDVI and GEMI can extract the water information from TM images well,while other vegetation indices can only separate vegetation from non-vegetation and are not suited to discriminate non-vegetation further.